Mamdani’s plan to break up NYPD’s riot unit called ‘smoke and mirrors’

Mamdani’s plan to break up NYPD’s riot unit called ‘smoke and mirrors’

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani says he will disband the NYPD’s Strategic Response Group and replace it with a civilian team focused on dialogue. But two former senior police officials argue the change may amount to a rebranding rather than a genuine dismantling of the unit.

Former NYPD Chief John Chell said many New Yorkers may find the plan confusing and feel uneasy about what it means in practice. In his view, the announcement is largely “smoke and mirrors.”

The proposed Community Dialogue and De-escalation Division would act as a buffer between demonstrators and uniformed officers, who are still expected to be present at major protests. Retired NYPD Inspector Paul Mauro noted that Mamdani has said officers could step in when stronger enforcement is needed. Mauro questioned how much would actually change beyond the unit’s name and the addition of civilian mediators.

Chell and Mauro said specialized officers would likely still be needed to manage large demonstrations, major crimes and counterterrorism threats. Chell described the plan as a possible rebranding of the SRG, while Mauro said the new civilian team would be placed between protesters and uniformed police.

Both former officials raised concerns that civilian mediators could slow police intervention if a peaceful gathering turns violent. Chell said officers who are forced to react instead of acting early may be less effective, potentially putting both police and the public at risk. Mauro warned that a situation could escalate before civilians have time to call for help.

The SRG receives information from the NYPD’s Intelligence and Counterterrorism Bureau about demonstrations that may pose a risk. Its officers are trained to handle crowds that become violent, starting with verbal de-escalation and, when necessary, moving people into police vehicles. Officers also use bicycles to form barriers and manage crowds.

Mauro said the unit was intended to bring in specially trained officers when protests began to get out of hand. It was deployed in only about 6% of protest-related situations, he said.

At a budget hearing earlier this year, officials said the SRG was generally used for protests that had turned violent, rather than peaceful gatherings. The NYPD reportedly facilitated 4,255 protests in 2025, with the SRG available for around 6% of them.

Critics, including the New York Civil Liberties Union, argue that the unit’s counterterrorism role contributes to aggressive policing and can undermine protections for free speech. A training manual reviewed for the report distinguishes between “peaceful/compliant” and “violent/non-compliant” crowds, and groups protesters into three categories: “everyday citizen,” “professional” and “anarchist.” Its description of an “everyday citizen” acknowledges the person’s First Amendment right to organize.

Even after the SRG is disbanded, police officers are expected to remain at larger demonstrations. The proposed civilian team would try to reduce tensions if a protest appeared to be turning violent. Mamdani has not said when that team will be formed or begin operating.

He has also announced a 30-officer NYPD First Amendment Support Team, which is intended to help de-escalate crowds while the civilian division is being developed.

Chell, who has said he plans to run for mayor in 2029, questioned whether the new team would be established before 2028, if it is created at all. He said he was concerned about the approach Mamdani and his advisers are taking toward public safety, warning that the city could be difficult to recover if their plans go too far.

The SRG training manual

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Telegram
WhatsApp

Related News