New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani says he wants to close the Rikers Island jail complex, but his proposal would keep it operating for at least five more years.
Mamdani announced the plan Friday in a social media video with Department of Correction Commissioner Stanley Richards, who was formerly incarcerated at Rikers. The mayor described the jail as one of the country’s most violent detention centers and said the city should focus more on what people need, rather than only on the charges they face.
The proposal calls for four jails in the boroughs to replace Rikers. The first is expected to open in 2029, with the others scheduled to follow by 2032. Richards said the facilities would be closer to public transportation, making it easier for people to visit family, meet with lawyers and get to court. He also said they would have fewer beds, which he argued could help staff keep people in custody safer.
Mamdani said the city would also provide hundreds of beds for people with serious mental illnesses. The plan still needs approval from the City Council.
The timeline would extend beyond the existing deadline to close Rikers, which was set in 2019 and calls for the complex to shut next year. In a podcast interview in 2020, Mamdani appeared to question the purpose of prisons, saying people should consider what role they serve and suggesting some supporters are drawn to the idea of incarceration and how it makes them feel.
The New York Post editorial board argued that the proposed borough jails are unlikely to be ready by the current closure deadline. It also noted that the plan provides for 4,100 beds, compared with Rikers’ capacity of 6,650, and said state law could prevent the city from closing the complex even after all four facilities are built.
The board criticized the effort to close Rikers as unrealistic, arguing instead that the city should build modern jails on the island.






