Mamdani’s tax on luxury second homes reaches $500 million despite thousands of exemptions

Mamdani’s tax on luxury homes reaches the $500 million mark despite thousands of exemptions

New York City bills luxury second-home owners more than $500 million under new surcharge

New York City has sent more than $500 million in tax bills to owners of qualifying second homes, Mayor Zohran Mamdani said Tuesday. The number of bills, however, was much lower than the city’s early estimates.

In a post on X, Mamdani said the city had billed owners of second homes valued above $5 million, calling the money a potential investment in services for New Yorkers.

City officials said the Department of Finance mailed about 7,500 bills. That is well below the roughly 17,000 initial notices sent to property owners over the summer. Officials also approved around 8,900 exemption requests and denied about 1,600 requests for extensions.

The surcharge is part of Mamdani’s effort to raise revenue from wealthier residents and help address the city’s budget shortfall. The amount billed exceeds the $500 million target Gov. Kathy Hochul outlined earlier this year, though officials have not provided a detailed breakdown of the total across the properties.

A Department of Finance spokesperson said the city would continue applying the surcharge, adding that owners of high-value second homes should contribute to the city that supports their property values.

The charge rises with a property’s value, so owners of more expensive homes may face larger bills.

A report from the city comptroller’s office in April estimated that a version of the tax could raise about $500 million from more than 11,200 properties before exemptions and changes in owner behavior were factored in. After accounting for those factors, the report projected revenue of roughly $340 million to $380 million.

Mamdani has remained confident the surcharge can bring in $500 million annually, telling reporters last week that the city stood by that estimate.

Approved by the state Legislature in May, the surcharge covers certain luxury second homes in New York City. It applies to some one- to three-family properties valued at $5 million or more, as well as condos and co-ops valued at $1 million or more. Owners who qualify for exemptions do not have to pay it.

The announcement followed a legal win for Mamdani earlier this month, when a state appeals court unanimously dismissed a lawsuit challenging the surcharge’s rollout. The court ruled that the homeowners who filed the case did not have legal standing, reversing a lower court order that had required the city to restart implementation.

Other legal challenges remain, including questions about whether the tax is constitutional.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Telegram
WhatsApp

Related News