- The Minnesota Supreme Court on Wednesday threw out Elsa Segura’s murder and kidnapping convictions.
- Segura was originally found guilty of aiding and abetting first-degree murder in the 2019 death of Monique Beau, a real estate agent who was lured to a fake home and murdered.
- “We have a duty to ensure that defendants in criminal trials are not convicted on the basis of insufficient evidence or erroneous jury instructions that are not harmless beyond a reasonable doubt,” the court’s ruling said. the judgment stated.
The Minnesota Supreme Court on Wednesday threw out the murder and kidnapping convictions of a former probation officer who was sentenced to life in prison without parole for his role in the death of a Minneapolis real estate agent.
The state Supreme Court ruled that prosecutors failed to present sufficient evidence to sustain a conviction on two of the four charges and that the trial judge asked the jury to determine her criminal liability. The court ruled that Elsa Segura was entitled to a new trial because of the incorrect instructions.
A jury in 2021 found Segura guilty of aiding and abetting first-degree premeditated murder in the 2019 New Year’s Eve killing of Monique Beaux. Prosecutors allege Segura lured Beau to a fake home showing in the Minneapolis suburb of Maple Grove.
Minneapolis man acquitted of triple murder, sentenced to 26 years in prison for kidnapping
In the early morning hours of 2020, Beau was found shot to death in a Minneapolis alley. The other three defendants were sentenced to life in prison without parole, and prosecutors said it was a plot aimed at getting revenge on Beau’s boyfriend, John Mitchell Momo. He was also a drug dealer. Beau’s boyfriend, who Wiggins allegedly considered an informant, was also shot, but survived.
The state Supreme Court earlier affirmed the convictions of two other defendants, but sentencing for Wiggins, the alleged mastermind of the conspiracy, is still pending.
The Minnesota Supreme Court has ruled that the woman charged in the death of Minneapolis real estate agent Monique Baugh is entitled to a new trial. (Fox News)
“Our opinion could lead to a new trial involving these difficult facts, further compounding the grief of those affected by the senseless act of violence perpetrated against Beau and her boyfriend. “We recognize that there is,” the judgment said. “Nevertheless, we have a duty to ensure that defendants in criminal trials are not convicted on the basis of insufficient evidence or erroneous jury instructions that are not harmless beyond a reasonable doubt. Masu.”
During his trial, Segura admitted to organizing the fake home show. She believed she was helping Wiggins with his drug business, she testified. But she claimed she had no knowledge of the plot to kidnap and kill Beau.
The majority said the evidence was sufficient to convict Mr. Segura of aiding and abetting first-degree felony murder and inflicting great bodily harm while committing kidnapping. But he said there was not enough evidence to convict her of aiding and abetting first-degree premeditated murder or attempted premeditated murder.
From the totality of the circumstances, the ruling said, it was reasonable to infer that Segura believed the original purpose of the conspiracy was something less serious than premeditated murder, perhaps kidnapping and assault.
CLICK HERE TO GET THE FOX NEWS APP
But the ruling said the trial judge’s error in jury instructions, an error in the law regarding accomplice liability, was significant enough to potentially affect the verdict. The high court therefore overturned her conviction and sent the case back to the lower court for further proceedings on the remaining kidnapping and felony murder charges.
