Concerns About New NYC Anti-Semitism Executive

New York City Mayor Zoran Mamdani has appointed Phyllisa Wisdom as the new head of the Mayor’s Office to Combat Anti-Semitism, raising eyebrows due to her longstanding anti-Israel sentiments. In the past, she expressed feeling “devastated” by a social media comment that criticized Hamas for bombarding civilian areas in Israel.

In 2021, Wisdom criticized then-mayoral candidate Andrew Yang for his condemnation of Hamas, who stated that he and New Yorkers stood in solidarity with Israel against terrorism.

Following Yang’s statement, Wisdom tweeted, expressing her shock—though not surprise—at his remarks, particularly during a period when Hamas had launched a significant attack that resulted in civilian casualties in Israel. Her tweet highlighted her perspective that New York should have leadership defending Palestinians amid perceived state violence.

Interestingly, Wisdom once posted about missing Yom Kippur, a significant Jewish holiday, humorously questioning how a Jewish person could feel joyous on such a day.

Identifying as a “liberal Zionist” supportive of a two-state solution for Israel and Palestine, Wisdom previously directed the New York Jewish Agenda, a group known for its critique of Israel’s military actions. The organization has financial backing from prominent entities like George Soros’ Open Society Foundations.

Mamdani’s choice of Wisdom comes as anti-Semitic hate crimes have reportedly surged in the city. Critics are voicing their concern that her leadership might exacerbate existing tensions.

Some city officials have expressed that the city deserves a less controversial figure for such a sensitive role, emphasizing the need for leadership that promotes unity rather than division.

State Assemblyman Kalman Jaeger raised questions about Mamdani’s decision, suggesting that Wisdom may not be the best fit for combatting anti-Semitism given her past remarks. He articulated the dilemma of appointing someone seen as controversial for this crucial position.

Wisdom takes over from Moshe Davis, who was previously appointed by former Mayor Eric Adams. Davis, troubled by Wisdom’s nomination, highlighted the challenges that arise when progressive values seemingly conflict with a clear stance for Jewish communities.

In response, Mamdani praised Wisdom as an influential leader in combating anti-Semitism, expressing his hope for a collaborative effort that emphasizes the safety and well-being of Jewish New Yorkers.