New York’s nightlife has always been vibrant, but these five unique bars are going above and beyond with their cool, quirky atmospheres.
From Bedford-Stuyvesant, where turtles race for glory, to Melville-inspired whaling taverns, the city’s bar scene is more than just nightlife; it’s an adventure.
Whether you’re in the mood for a horror-themed haunt or want to sip a martini under a ceiling adorned with hot air balloons, these spots blend personality with a lively drink selection.
Here are five distinctive bars that showcase just how unconventional New York can be.
Where is the witch’s time?
Located in Ridgewood, Queens, Flying Fox Tavern is a dream come true for horror enthusiasts. This spot is filled with gothic chandeliers, creepy decor, and enough red lighting to make anyone feel like they’ve stepped into a haunted house.
Since opening in 2022, it has quickly become a favorite for fright fans. Co-owner Tracy Bradbury came up with the idea after realizing that New York had very few horror-themed bars left.
“We wanted to create a space for movie and music lovers, offering excellent food and drinks too,” Bradbury shared, emphasizing a blend of fun and quality.
Guests enter beneath a glowing neon bat sign and can enjoy themed picnic tables in the backyard. Inside, the ambiance is all about gothic elegance mixed with monster movie memorabilia.
The bar aims to foster inclusivity, attracting a wide audience, from families to classic horror fans. Surprisingly, the menu has healthy options, featuring vegan dishes and innovative vampire-themed cocktails.
Where cocktails meet the high seas – and Herman Melville
Quick Etern, a newly opened bar in the seaport area, draws inspiration from Herman Melville’s classic, featuring cocktails named after quotes from “Moby-Dick.”
This spot, which opened in May, captures the essence of old Cape Cod taverns with a modern twist. Owner Brian Schneider found his muse while reading Melville, leading to a space rich with nautical themes.
With onboard decor and specialized cocktails, the atmosphere invites patrons to immerse themselves in literary seafaring adventures.
Customers have been frequenting the bar, drawn by their love for “Moby-Dick” and the unique offerings of the menu, which includes delectable crab fritters and a standout lobster puppy dish.
Groundbreaking journalism, Globe Trottinggram, where gin collides
Miss Nelly, a whimsical new speakeasy in Hell’s Kitchen, draws inspiration from intrepid journalist Nelly Bly. This bar melds storytelling with mixology, captivating visitors since its opening.
General Manager Marisabrad notes that every element—from decor to cocktails—tells a story celebrating adventure and bold femininity. Locals see it as a cozy escape, while visitors often describe it as a hidden treasure.
Signature cocktails, like “Fogg & Fancy,” are served in creatively designed glassware, enhancing the overall experience. The food, from spicy chicken bites to gourmet dips, has garnered quite the following thanks to its clever twists on classic comfort food.
Where the drinks are cold, the turtle is bold – and the lace is authentic
In Bed-Stuy, “Turtles All the Way Down” has introduced an unconventional twist to the bar scene with its monthly turtle races, where guests cheer on fan favorites like Ja Rule and Vita.
Since its inception in 2017, the cozy bar offers a laid-back vibe and a fun atmosphere, encouraging social engagement through its unique race events.
Alongside a menu filled with simple comfort foods and refreshing cocktails, the gathering spot has become a local favorite, especially during race days which include special drinks and DJ entertainment.
There is a golden hour on the deck every hour
Sailor’s Choice is a unique dockside bar located near Hudson Yards, featuring a vintage fishing boat as part of its decor. The nautical theme is complemented by refreshing cocktails, making for an inviting atmosphere.
Owned by the Miles brothers and Alex Pincus, this spot embodies their long-standing passion for boating. The outdoor layout, complete with striped umbrellas, offers a relaxing space to enjoy quality drinks and coastal favorites.
Guests can sample dishes like lobster BLT and crispy fish and chips, all while basking in the sun. The bar’s offerings promise to deliver delightful flavors and a chill ambiance perfect for a day by the water.
