No Justice Jackson, That’s Not What the Supreme Court Should Do

No Justice Jackson, That’s Not What the Supreme Court Should Do

Supreme Court Ruling in FS Credit Opportunities Corp. v. Saba Capital

Amidst the notable Supreme Court decisions during the 2025-26 term, the case of FS Credit Opportunities Corp. v. Saba Capital Master Fund, Ltd. might seem rather unremarkable at first. It determined that Section 47(b) of the Investment Company Act does not allow for private lawsuits aimed at rescinding certain contracts.

However, in Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson’s dissent, there’s a striking sentence that unveils her distinct judicial philosophy.

This isn’t the first instance where Jackson has characterized her role in unconventional terms. Take her book tour last year, for example, when she expressed, “I just feel that I have a wonderful opportunity to tell people in my opinions how I feel about the issues, and that’s what I try to do.”

In FS Credit, though, she didn’t just talk about her individual role but also addressed the function of the Supreme Court as an institution, stating, “The Court’s proper role is to give effect to the will of the people.”

That certainly sounds democratic, but it diverges from the beliefs of America’s founders. They established a system where the legislative branch, not the judiciary, is responsible for translating the people’s will.

As James Madison outlined in The Federalist No. 52, the House of Representatives has an “immediate dependence on, and an intimate sympathy with, the people.” Meanwhile, The Federalist No. 63 explains that the Senate deliberates on legislation in a more thoughtful manner. This process illustrates how Congress conveys the current will of the populace into law.

On the other hand, the judiciary’s link to the “will of the people” operates quite differently. The Constitution grants the judiciary the power to interpret and apply the law to resolve legal disputes.

Just a few years post-ratification, the Supreme Court affirmed that the Constitution “contains the permanent will of the people.” The judiciary is tasked with upholding this permanent will by interpreting the Constitution as the people originally intended.

Interestingly, during her 2022 confirmation hearing, Jackson appeared to grasp this concept. She stated to the Senate, “The adherence to text is a constraint on my authority. I’m focusing on the original public meaning [of the Constitution] because I’m constrained to interpret the text.”

She even used the term “original public meaning” multiple times, which led many to doubt her genuine commitment to this principle. Her dissent in FS Credit adds to the belief that this was merely confirmation rhetoric.

While examining Section 47(b), Jackson initially focused on the text, structure, and legislative history. The Supreme Court has repeatedly emphasized that “where…the words of the statute are unambiguous, the judicial inquiry is complete.” Courts “may not resort to extrinsic evidence to interpret them.” Yet, Jackson attempted to do just that, arguing that committee reports indicated Congress intended for courts to acknowledge a private right to sue—contradicting the statute itself.

References from the legislative process can reflect the thoughts of some legislators or committee members, yet the ruling in FS Credit stated that “Congress expresses itself as a body through the text it enacts.” The opinions of congressional committees “are not the law.”

The Supreme Court famously declared in Marbury v. Madison that “it is emphatically the duty of the Judicial Department to say what the law is.”

In the context of FS Credit, the law entails the text Congress enacted, interpreted according to Congress’s intentions. A judge shouldn’t seek alternative sources to determine a case in a preferred manner. Relying on “the will of the people” as justification doesn’t alter that reality.

Jackson’s earlier mentions of “original public meaning” during her confirmation hearing illustrated how the judiciary is meant to operate. Yet her dissent in FS Credit reveals a disconnect, reminiscent of Texas Republican Sen. Ted Cruz’s comment that it was merely a “confirmation-day conversion.”

The Supreme Court lacks the authority to sift through the “will of the people” to find justifications for its actions.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Telegram
WhatsApp

Related News