NWSL Addresses Controversy Over Genetic Testing

The National Women’s Soccer League (NWSL) issued a statement on Tuesday regarding a recent uproar concerning players who didn’t pass genetic tests.

This statement specifically defended Barbra Banda, a striker for Orlando Pride, who was deemed ineligible to play for Zambia in the 2022 World Cup qualifying tournament because her testosterone levels exceeded those permitted by the Confederation of African Football.

This comes on the heels of an op-ed by Elizabeth Eddy of Angel City FC that was published in the New York Post last week, advocating for the NWSL to implement stricter gender eligibility regulations.

“Barbra Banda is a top player in the NWSL. Her recognition in the FIFPRO World Eleven, determined solely by her fellow players, highlights her incredible talent and dedication,” the statement read. “The harassment and negative treatment she faces are intolerable and have no place in our sport or community. We stand firmly with Barbra and all NWSL athletes.”

Simultaneously, the Orlando Pride released a comparable statement defending Banda, praising her contributions to the team and the league. “Barbra is an exemplary teammate and role model. We are proud to have her represent Orlando Pride. Her recent selection to the FIFPRO World 11 for the second consecutive year is a testament to her impact in the sport,” the team expressed.

Reactions to the statement have been mixed on social media. Eddy’s editorial ignited a discussion among fans and led to criticism from some of his teammates. In her piece, Eddy called for clear standards from the NWSL, suggesting that only players “born with ovaries” should compete, following the guidelines set by the British Women’s Super League.

“Fairness and inclusion are fundamental American values. While reasonable people might disagree on where to draw the line, silencing diverse perspectives doesn’t help. We owe it to current and future female athletes to confront this issue,” she wrote.

During a team press conference over the weekend, Eddy’s Angel City FC teammates Sarah Gorden and Angelina Anderson addressed the op-ed. Gorden expressed that many within the locker room were hurt and offended by the article, noting that its content seemed transphobic and racially charged. “It’s damaging to single out these athletes based on their appearance or differences. As a mixed woman with a black family, I find the implications of this piece shocking,” she stated.

Anderson emphasized the importance of the team’s values. “When I think of Angel City, I envision a place built on inclusivity. That’s who we are as a team and as a fan community. This has been our mission from the start, and it will always be.”

She also acknowledged the timing of the situation and its challenges for the team during an already difficult season. “We want to end on a positive note, maintaining respect and unity in our locker room,” Anderson added.