Controversial Children’s Book Remains in Orange County Libraries

A children’s book featuring explicit illustrations of animal mating, which sparked debate in Orange County, Florida, will still be available in four middle school libraries. This decision came after a school board vote this month.

The book in question is titled “Do Animals Fall in Love?” and was authored by German sex education expert Katharina von der Garten. It’s described by its publisher as a straightforward and candid look at animal reproduction and courtship behaviors. Aimed at children aged six and older, it aims to assist adults in discussing puberty and sex education in a way that’s, well, a bit more detached—using the animal kingdom as a backdrop.

During a school board meeting on January 13, members voted 6-2 to keep the book on library shelves. Alicia Farrant and board president Teresa Jacobs opposed the decision.

The controversy began when some parents raised concerns about the book’s content, leading to a request for reconsideration. One parent expressed worries, mentioning that the book depicts sexual acts between various animal species, including group behaviors. Additionally, reports highlighted its “vivid” portrayals of animal anatomy.

Farrant voiced her doubts about the book’s suitability for middle schoolers, citing her youngest son, who is in fifth grade. She couldn’t fathom him receiving such a book in sixth grade, labeling it as “another perversion.”

Despite this, the Literacy Committee recommended maintaining the book on the shelves due to its educational potential, noting its alignment with sixth and seventh-grade science standards. Some supporters argued that the book presents a fascinating exploration of animal reproduction.

Stephanie Banos, a board member, praised the book’s engaging approach, suggesting that it could pique students’ interest in learning.

Fellow board member Vicki Elaine Felder emphasized the importance of parental choice, insisting that families should have the authority to select what’s appropriate for their children. She supported the book’s presence in schools.

Florida law mandates that school districts provide a process for parents to limit their child’s access to library materials. Farrant, however, intends to push for the book’s removal, pointing out parental concerns about the content.

Von der Garten has mentioned that her motivation for writing the book stemmed from children’s questions about animal reproduction and sexual behavior. She collaborated with experts at the Leipzig Zoo for the book’s content, which has reportedly been translated into 15 languages since its 2017 release in German.