Person in the country illegally faces no charges after a Florida grandmother is killed outside a grocery store, angering her family.

Person in the country illegally faces no charges after a Florida grandmother is killed outside a grocery store, angering her family.

Charges Dropped in Fatal Florida Parking Lot Crash

Prosecutors have dropped the case against a Venezuelan man accused of backing over and killing 82-year-old Deborah Murphy in a grocery store parking lot in Panama City Beach. Florida’s Fourteenth Judicial Circuit State Attorney Larry Basford said the driver will not face charges related to the crash.

Basford said prosecutors spent nearly six months examining the case but could not establish the evidence required for a conviction. He described the driver’s actions as careless and negligent, while noting that negligence alone does not necessarily amount to a crime.

Murphy’s daughters, Amy Edge and Beth Schulz, said the decision was devastating. They said both sets of the vehicle’s tires passed over their mother before it stopped.

On May 17, Murphy had finished a brief visit to a Publix and was walking through a crosswalk toward her car with a bag. Surveillance footage shows a Toyota 4Runner reversing into her. She was facing away from the SUV and apparently did not see it coming. The vehicle continued backward after knocking her down, according to a Florida Highway Patrol arrest affidavit.

The driver, Carlos Suarez-Contreras, was 26 and in the United States illegally, according to arrest records. He was driving with a Georgia license that had been canceled. He was initially charged with driving with a canceled license and causing a death, a third-degree felony.

Murphy was taken to a hospital, where she died less than an hour later from blunt-force injuries, her daughters said.

One obstacle for prosecutors was proving Suarez-Contreras knew his license had been canceled. The Georgia Department of Driver Services confirmed the cancellation but declined to say when it happened or when he would have been notified, citing privacy concerns. The license became invalid just one day before the crash, Basford said.

Georgia requires non-U.S. citizens who establish residency in the state to obtain a Georgia license within 30 days. State rules describe residency as including, among other circumstances, accepting employment in Georgia or remaining in the state for at least 30 days.

Prosecutors also considered vehicular homicide and manslaughter charges, but Basford said they could not demonstrate the level of culpable negligence those offenses require. Investigators used the surveillance footage to reconstruct the crash. Their review led them to conclude that the SUV was not reversing fast enough to establish that Suarez-Contreras had acted recklessly.

Florida’s 2023 law invalidates certain licenses issued to undocumented immigrants by states including California, Connecticut and Delaware. Georgia is not among the states covered by the law, Basford said.

The passenger in the SUV, Luis Sanabria, told a law enforcement officer under oath that Suarez-Contreras had been driving. An incident report said Sanabria had an expired visa. He was later released to the custody of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, according to a Bay County Sheriff’s Office spokesperson.

Suarez-Contreras was initially held without bond because of his immigration status and concerns that he might flee, according to Florida Highway Patrol records. After the case was dropped, he was transferred to ICE custody on November 15, the Bay County Jail said. His defense attorney said he was pleased the charges had been dismissed.

Murphy’s daughters said they felt let down by the state and questioned how the investigation was handled, including the weight given to the crash reconstruction. They also asked why Suarez-Contreras was not tested for drugs or alcohol and why investigators did not review his phone records. Their mother, they said, underwent toxicology testing.

Edge said her mother had been in good health and could have had many more years with her family. She will not be there for her grandchildren’s weddings or meet any more of her great-grandchildren, Edge said.

The sisters said they may seek changes to Florida law or to how similar crashes are investigated. Their aim, Edge said, is not revenge but helping prevent another family from experiencing the same loss.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Telegram
WhatsApp

Related News