After the Rams fell short in a 31-27 loss to the Seahawks in the NFC Championship game, coach Sean McVay expressed deep worries about the future of the team. When asked about Matthew Stafford’s return in 2026, McVay’s response— “What kind of question is that?”—revealed more than just frustration; it hinted at an underlying uncertainty. Even if Stafford decides to continue next season, the Rams might be staring into the void that follows the departure of a franchise quarterback, with no apparent plan in place.
Stafford is set to turn 38 soon and just had the best season of his lengthy 17-year career, leading the NFL in both passing yards and touchdowns. He played as though he had discovered the secret to time management and appeared a strong candidate for league MVP. Recently, he mentioned on a podcast that he enjoys playing with the Rams and desires time to think about his future before making any life-altering decisions.
This sentiment feels entirely reasonable. Given his accomplishments, one could argue he’s earned that right.
However, if it were McVay in this situation, the anxiety would likely escalate.
Because if Stafford suddenly decides to retire—despite any pain he might feel—the Rams wouldn’t just lose their quarterback. They would lose the foundational element that shapes the team’s entire strategy. The dynamics of their offense, the protective schemes, the overall atmosphere during plays; all would shift dramatically, all at once.
So the pivotal question for the Rams remains: “What comes next?”
Option 1: Promote from within
One straight route is to promote from within the organization. This option feels straightforward, though it may not be thrilling. Jimmy Garoppolo, who has experience including a Super Bowl appearance, is a name that comes to mind. McVay seems to trust him. If Stafford were to suddenly retire, Garoppolo could take charge, with Stetson Bennett serving as backup. But, it’s worth noting that Garoppolo has yet to shine in critical moments.
Option 2: Free Agent
Entering free agency presents both enticing opportunities and risks. If Tua Tagovailoa were available, enticing as it seems, his medical history raises concerns. McVay has typically preferred stability in the quarterback position since joining the team in 2017, so this may not be the route he would take.
Malik Willis stands out as a more intriguing possibility. He’s dynamic and brings a different flavor to the game. The idea of using him in McVay’s system isn’t out of the question. Willis has shown growth, especially during his time with the Packers, and he could complicate defenses with his agility.
With several teams showing interest in Willis, including the Dolphins, it’s not a guaranteed win for the Rams. Unless they see him as a long-term solution, this could prove a risky move financially and strategically.
Option 3: Draft Stafford’s successor
The upcoming NFL Draft also poses both hope and uncertainty.
This year’s quarterback pool seems lacking. There are likely only two quarterbacks projected for the first round. Fernando Mendoza appears to be heading to the Raiders at No. 1 overall. Then, it becomes a matter of speculation rather than reassurance. Ty Simpson might align with what the Rams need, but acquiring him could mean trading up and sacrificing valuable resources while the roster remains competitive.
This brings up a fascinating yet risky option: do nothing at the quarterback position. The Rams own two first-round picks in 2026 and could bolster their roster instead, perhaps adding another key defender or weapon for Stafford. Then, in 2027, they could enter a stronger QB draft class.
Arch Manning is notable among that potential crop. The Rams have a keen interest in him due to his attributes and overall potential. If not Manning, there are likely other quarterbacks in 2027 who could be cultivated to fit McVay’s setup.
This route demands patience, which can be precarious, particularly if Stafford’s timeline doesn’t align with the Rams’ aspirations.
Option 4: Once Stafford retires, blow everything up.
Amid all of this lies a more daunting reality that few want to voice.
What if Stafford retires and McVay follows suit?
He flirted with the idea after the 2022 Super Bowl and did so again following a difficult season. His exit from coaching could transform the organization’s landscape overnight, making the search for new leadership both daunting and exhaustive.
Davante Adams has noted this shift. He recognizes how special it is to be part of this Rams environment. He advised teammates to appreciate their surroundings, suggesting that they might not find an opportunity as valuable as their current one.
Ultimately, this reflects the Rams’ deeper plans—not just for finding Stafford’s replacement, but for ensuring that the right people remain in key positions to maintain continuity. Striking a balance is essential here. Stafford deserves time, and the Rams need clarity in their future direction. They can’t afford to be caught off guard, as they were when they lost Von Miller after the 2022 Super Bowl. A scramble then could lead them down a challenging path.
