Recognize the socialists and communists allegedly driving “grassroots” protests against data centers

Recognize the socialists and communists allegedly driving “grassroots” protests against data centers

The campaign opposing a proposed $5 billion data center in Landover, Maryland, has been described as a grassroots effort. But its rapid growth may have had help from outside the community. Local organizer Taylor Frazier McCollum has said the opposition is homegrown, while the petition gathered more than 25,000 signatures with substantial online promotion from the Party for Socialism and Liberation. The group has also been linked to millionaire Neville Roy Singham, who has reportedly had close ties to China’s Communist Party.

Even without questions about possible financial backing, some of the campaign’s language seems overstated. After celebrating the delay of a project proposed for a long-abandoned site, some opponents compared their zoning fight to Martin Luther King Jr.’s civil rights movement.

Residents have every right to raise concerns. But likening a dispute over a data center and zoning permits to the struggle in Selma is a stretch. The protests may be dramatic; the comparison is more so.

There is a familiar contradiction underneath it all: people rely on cloud services every day, but often want the infrastructure that supports them built somewhere else.

Arrogance versus foolishness

We spend much of our lives using screens to stream films, trade stocks, order groceries, and ask AI for advice. Yet the physical systems behind those services can be treated as if they were industrial hazards. The cloud is not some invisible mist. It depends on vast buildings, cooling equipment, wiring, and backup generators. People expect online banking to work smoothly and video calls to stay clear, then object when a technology company proposes a facility nearby.

That does not mean tech companies deserve a free pass. They sometimes arrive in small communities expecting approval without serious questions. Residents are right to ask about the costs: data centers use substantial amounts of electricity and water. Their share of U.S. electricity use could reach about 17% by 2030, while estimates put their direct water use for cooling at more than 17 billion gallons annually.

Local households should not be left paying for grid upgrades needed by a large new facility. Nor should elected officials offer generous tax breaks lasting decades to enormous corporations that may employ relatively few people once construction ends. Communities can demand clear disclosures, require companies to cover the cost of grid expansion, encourage closed-loop cooling, and insist on meaningful local investment.

Recognizing those risks is a case for sensible rules, not for shutting down development altogether. Air travel uses fuel, but that does not mean airports should never be built. Power plants produce emissions, yet few people want to give up electricity. The challenge is to manage the impact, not pretend the modern economy can run on good intentions alone.

Too often, practical questions about infrastructure turn into ideological fights. The familiar “not in my backyard” response surfaces whenever construction is proposed. People say they want affordable housing, better transit, reliable energy, and stronger communities—until an apartment building, transmission line, or data center is proposed nearby. In Maryland, turning away a major investment could leave the community with the same neglected, paved-over former shopping center, but without the promised tax revenue. Rejecting a project is straightforward. Finding a better use for the site is harder.

Lazy arguments are losing arguments

Supporters of major infrastructure projects sometimes fall back on a familiar line: if the United States does not build, China will win. That may sound persuasive in some settings, but it is unlikely to convince residents who are worried about power bills and water supplies. People in Prince George’s County are not necessarily willing to shoulder those costs simply to give a technology company an advantage in the race to develop AI.

National security matters, and losing ground to a powerful rival could carry serious consequences. Still, invoking China does not make a weak business arrangement fair. People need direct reasons to support large projects: lower property taxes, funding for schools, improved local power systems, and firm environmental protections.

Americans should not have to choose between unchecked construction and a system where every project is stalled indefinitely. China can build power plants and data centers quickly in part because residents have far fewer ways to challenge the government. That is not a model the United States should copy. Property rights and democratic accountability matter. But accountability should not become a permanent veto that kills every proposal through endless procedural delays.

There is room for compromise. Technology companies can build infrastructure the economy increasingly depends on, while paying the full cost of doing so. That could mean binding protections against sharp increases in household utility rates, water-efficient cooling requirements, and tax incentives tied to measurable community benefits. Permitting decisions should also have clear, reasonable deadlines.

The United States has built towering cities, rail lines across the continent, and spacecraft capable of reaching the moon. It should be possible to develop the infrastructure of this century without turning every zoning dispute into a historic crusade—or treating every local opponent as a civil rights icon.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Telegram
WhatsApp

Related News