The first three rounds of the 2026 NFL Draft have wrapped up, leaving only the much-anticipated third day. While many casual fans might tune out during Saturday’s event, dedicated followers know that the real gems often appear on that final day.
It’s quite fascinating, really—some of the standout players we’ve seen over the last 15 years were passed over for various reasons, only to be picked up later in the draft. So, today, let’s take a fun little trip down memory lane and explore some of the best late-round picks since the NFL Draft transitioned to a three-day format back in 2010.
Now, this means we’ll skip over legends like Tom Brady and Shannon Sharpe—sorry, Patriots and Broncos fans. Just trying to keep things fresh here. Let’s get started!
Geno Atkins – Cincinnati Bengals (4th Rd, 2010)
Kicking off our list, we have Geno Atkins. He was a somewhat undersized defensive tackle from Georgia, drafted by the Cincinnati Bengals in the fourth round of 2010. Initially, he started low on the Bengals’ depth chart but quickly made his mark, earning a starting position and becoming a dominant force on the defensive line. Over time, he proved to be one of the best in his position, boasting eight Pro Bowl selections and five first-team All-Pro honors. Not too shabby for a fourth-round pick who weighed in at just 290 pounds out of college!
Richard Sherman – Seattle Seahawks (5th Rd, 2011)
Next up, we have Richard Sherman. The Seahawks snagged him in the fifth round of the 2011 draft, thinking he’d mainly serve as depth. Little did they know he’d become a cornerstone of the Legion of Boom. During his time in Seattle, Sherman earned five Pro Bowl nods and three first-team All-Pro selections, helping the Seahawks secure their first Super Bowl title. It’s impressive—fifth-rounders typically don’t have careers like his.
Maxx Crosby – Las Vegas Raiders (4th Rd, 2019)
Now, moving to a more recent standout: Maxx Crosby from the 2019 NFL Draft. The former Eastern Michigan edge rusher was largely overlooked and taken by the then-Oakland Raiders in the fourth round, at pick 106. Initially, there were doubts about his ability to even make the team. Fast forward, and Crosby has racked up five Pro Bowl appearances, two All-Pro selections, and close to 70 sacks. It’s safe to say the Raiders hit the jackpot! Plus, he’s managed to overcome personal challenges while crafting a potential Hall of Fame career.
Jason Kelce – Philadelphia Eagles (2011 Game 6)
Jason Kelce might be a household name now, known for his Super Bowl win and podcasting, but he started off as a sixth-round pick out of Cincinnati. Back then, he was competing for a roster spot after playing various positions. The Eagles picked him, and he eventually found his niche on the offensive line. Fast forward to today, and he’s a seven-time Pro Bowler and a six-time All-Pro. Not to mention, he’s a beloved figure in Philadelphia. This all began on that fateful third day of the 2011 draft.
Tyreek Hill – Kansas City Chiefs (5th Rd, 2016)
Last but certainly not least, we have Tyreek Hill. With some off-field issues leading many to believe he’d go undrafted, the Kansas City Chiefs picked him up in the fifth round of 2016. This turned out to be one of their smartest moves. Hill redefined what it means to be a deep threat. His speed and capability on the field, combined with a new partnership with quarterback Patrick Mahomes, led the Chiefs to a Super Bowl title and numerous passing records. With five first-team All-Pro selections and eight Pro Bowl appearances under his belt, he stands out among the best, particularly for a fifth-round pick.
So, there you have it—success doesn’t always come from being a first-round selection. It’s a reminder as we look ahead to the upcoming draft. Who’s your favorite late-round pick? Let’s hear it!
