Retired police sergeant warns about Mamdani’s NYPD changes before the Thanksgiving parade

Retired police sergeant warns about Mamdani’s NYPD changes before the Thanksgiving parade

Retired sergeant warns against visiting New York as mayor moves to disband NYPD unit

A retired police sergeant with nearly 30 years of law enforcement experience says she would not bring her family to New York City as Mayor Zohran Mamdani moves to dismantle a specialized NYPD unit involved in counterterrorism support and crowd control.

“I wouldn’t take my family there right now,” said Betsy Brantner Smith, a retired sergeant and spokesperson for the National Police Association.

Mamdani has announced plans to disband the Strategic Response Group, a unit of about 500 officers that supports counterterrorism operations, security at major events and responses to protests. The change is part of a broader overhaul of how the department handles demonstrations.

The mayor, a democratic socialist, has said the move fulfills a campaign promise to separate counterterrorism work from policing constitutionally protected protests. Critics worry that breaking up the unit could weaken the coordination and specialized training needed during emergencies.

Smith, who worked in law enforcement in the Chicago area for 29 years and supervised crowd-control operations, said the effects could reach beyond protests.

Officers in the unit, she said, regularly train and work together, building specialized knowledge that helps them respond quickly and safely to situations such as an active shooter incident.

Her concerns come as New York prepares for the 100th Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade on Nov. 26, which is expected to draw large crowds to Manhattan. Smith said dismantling the unit could create gaps if its duties are reassigned without maintaining established working relationships. She also worried that intelligence gathered for a major event might be lost or overlooked.

NYPD Assistant Commissioner Brad Weeks said the restructuring would not affect security for this year’s parade. The new First Amendment Support Team and Patrol Support Division are not expected to begin operating until February 2027.

The department said counterterrorism personnel currently assigned to the Strategic Response Group will move to the NYPD’s Counterterrorism Bureau.

Mamdani’s office referred questions to comments he made at a news conference. He said counterterrorism and protest response are different responsibilities, and people exercising their right to protest should not face the same police response as a terrorism threat.

The changes also place new limits on police tactics at protests. The mayor’s office said officers will be prohibited from using long guns and tear gas, and pepper spray will no longer be allowed as a general crowd-control measure. Officers in the Patrol Support Division will receive specialized training and retain the authority to make arrests when needed.

Mamdani said the first changes would take effect in about 90 days. During the transition, a First Amendment Support Team will operate within the NYPD’s Community Affairs Bureau.

A separate, civilian-led Community Dialogue and De-escalation Division is planned for 2028 under the Office of Community Safety. The mayor said it would work with protest organizers, mediate disputes and try to prevent tensions from rising.

Mamdani rejected claims that civilians would be left to confront violent demonstrators without police assistance, saying officers would be present whenever violence occurred.

Smith questioned whether the new structure could retain the capabilities of officers who are accustomed to responding together during major incidents. She called the decision political and dangerous.

Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch defended the changes, saying the department would keep the resources required to respond to serious threats. She said she would not support changes that reduced the NYPD’s ability to protect residents or left officers without the tools they needed.

The announcement was welcomed by several left-wing activist groups that have criticized the NYPD’s approach to demonstrations. The Party for Socialism and Liberation said the disbanding followed a mass movement, while adding that its broader fight would continue.

Nerdeen Kiswani, founder of the activist group Within Our Lifetime, called the decision overdue and welcome. Marxist streamer Hasan Piker also praised Mamdani for following through on the promise. It remains unclear whether the groups or public figures influenced the mayor’s decision.

The National Police Association has started a petition urging Mamdani to reverse course, arguing that the unit’s specialized skills are important for public safety. Organizers said it drew nearly 2,000 signatures in its first two days.

Smith urged the mayor to preserve the NYPD’s ability to deploy officers with established training and experience, saying the department should be allowed to use every tool available to keep the city safe.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Telegram
WhatsApp

Related News