Teachers union president Randi Weingarten and her allies are arguing that Republicans lost support in the midterms because of school choice. Weingarten said voters rejected school funding cuts, conservative culture-war politics and privatization. The available evidence, however, does not clearly support that explanation.
Texas governor-elect Gina Hinojosa criticized school choice in her election-night speech, vowing to address what she called the damage caused by the state’s voucher program. Democrats in Texas have since proposed ending scholarships for more than 100,000 students, many from low-income families. That stance sits uneasily alongside their campaign focus on affordability. Several Democratic state senators backing the proposals attended private schools themselves or sent their children to them.
Interest in Texas’s Education Freedom Accounts also complicates the claim that voters rejected school choice. In the program’s first year, more than 274,000 students applied, and over 100,000 received funding. Tens of thousands more families were waitlisted after the money ran out.
Exit polls from 2022 and 2026 suggest Gov. Greg Abbott’s share of the rural vote stayed about the same, at roughly 64% to 66%. His statewide vote share shifted nine points to the left as part of a broader Democratic wave, but rural support for him held steady. If rural voters had turned against Abbott over school choice, the polling might be expected to show a decline there. It did not.
Education was also well below the economy and immigration among voters’ leading concerns. And while Democrats flipped more than 20 Republican-held seats in the Texas House, just one of those gains came in the state’s 30 most rural districts, which remained strongly Republican.
Voters recently rejected nearly $7 billion in proposed public-school funding, about 85% of the total amount considered on the ballot. The year before, they approved a higher homestead exemption from school district property taxes by a wide margin: 79.4% to 20.6%. Those results suggest voters were more interested in lowering property taxes than putting additional money into public schools.
An October University of Texas at Austin poll found voters trusted Hinojosa and Abbott about equally on public education. Democrats have usually enjoyed a double-digit advantage on education, so Hinojosa’s lack of an edge may indicate that her platform did not persuade voters on the issue. Other surveys have found support for school choice: a 2024 University of Houston poll reported that 69% of Texas voters backed universal education savings accounts, while a University of Texas at Tyler poll found 60% support in 2023.
School choice has also had strong backing among Texas Republican primary voters. In 2022, 88% supported it in a ballot question, with similar support in large and small counties. Candidates opposed to school choice have faced political trouble, too. In 2024, incumbent Glenn Rogers lost his primary by 27 points.
The Dallas Morning News published an opinion piece by Suzanne Bellsnyder, described as a longtime Republican, arguing that rural Republicans were moving toward Hinojosa. The paper later said its editors had not known Bellsnyder’s firm received $57,000 from the Hinojosa campaign, and that they would not have run the piece if they had. The article remained online.
The claim that school choice harms rural communities is not convincing, in my view. As more options become available, families can still choose their local public school. They simply do not have to stay there if it is not working for them. And competition may push public schools to improve, though that outcome is not automatic.
Some of the country’s oldest voucher programs began in Maine and Vermont in the late 19th century, serving children in rural areas without public schools. Those programs are still in place. The lesson, at least, is that limited options can be a reason to broaden educational access rather than restrict it.
Mississippi and Alaska both elected Democratic senators despite having no universal school-choice program. That points to a wider national shift, not a backlash against school choice alone.
It is possible Hinojosa might have won by more had she supported parents who favor school choice. The evidence does not show that the issue cost Abbott the election. But efforts to take scholarships away from families who already rely on them could carry political consequences. Parents who gain access to school choice tend to work hard to keep it.






