Spencer Pratt criticizes New York City Mayor Mamdani for his July 4th speech

Spencer Pratt Criticizes NYC Mayor’s July 4th Speech

Spencer Pratt has voiced strong criticism of New York City Mayor Zoran Mamdani for his remarks about American history during the Fourth of July celebrations, igniting a considerable online backlash over the holiday weekend.

Pratt, who rose to fame as a reality TV star and made headlines with his unexpected run for mayor in Los Angeles, has expanded his political commentary to include Mamdani. The mayor marked the country’s 250th Independence Day with a speech on immigration from George Washington’s desk. He was joined by eight new citizens and took the opportunity to denounce U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) official Elon Musk, labeling America an “arena of hegemony.”

In his speech, Mamdani reflected on the “contradictions” present in the nation, pointing out issues like wealth disparity and social injustices. He remarked, “We see the richest country in history where children go hungry… monopolies that control every industry… undercover agents terrorizing the streets, yet still benefiting from our undocumented neighbors’ labor.”

In a viral response video, Pratt accused Mamdani of adhering to a communist ideology that attacks American history. “Why do communists attack your history?” he questioned, “Because it binds you to your identity.”

Pratt condemned Mamdani, the self-described communist mayor, stating, “We all had to witness that scumbag lecture us about our history.” Dressed in a “Socialist Social Club” shirt, he made these comments while stationed next to his RV, in front of where his home used to be, before it was lost to a fire.

“Communists destroy history to reshape society,” Pratt elaborated, firmly asserting that loving America is not just acceptable but vital. He encouraged Americans to “think of your country as home,” suggesting that memories define our sense of belonging.

While acknowledging that U.S. history is fraught with conflict, he emphasized its role in building strength and identity. “Bad times contribute to who we are,” he noted, and he accused Mamdani of having no authority to redefine American history or values.

Mamdani, a naturalized citizen from Uganda, countered in his speech by asserting that all Americans have the right to define what America represents. He elaborated, saying those in power have historically shaped the narrative to maintain control, emphasizing that “not all people are created equal.”

He also observed that the idea of American exceptionalism often overlooks the inherent flexibility and ongoing challenge of embodying the values set out in the Declaration of Independence. This, he argued, is a task that remains in the hands of all citizens, including new Americans who stand alongside him.