Free Speech Discussions at University of North Dakota
At the University of North Dakota School of Law, the Federalist Society emphasizes the importance of diverse viewpoints. Ahead of the “This Is the Turning Point” tour by Turning Point USA (TPUSA), members Sarah Ziegler and Naomi Blomke shared their thoughts on the significance of open dialogue and their commitment to speaking out, despite facing opposition.
Sarah reflected on TPUSA’s influence, noting, “I don’t think there’s another organization making as much impact on college campuses. It seems students are becoming more aware, realizing they can’t just passively accept everything. They’re ready to advocate for their beliefs.” This conversation follows a situation at Rutgers University, where the local TPUSA chapter started a petition to remove Professor Mark Bray due to his earlier remarks in support of Antifa.
A counter-petition has emerged, urging action against Rutgers University itself. The TPUSA chapter claims conservative groups contribute to a “toxic environment” and advocate “hate speech.”
Naomi pointed out that those opposing Turning Point “don’t want to listen to the alternative perspective.” She argued, “People claiming to support free speech but opposing TPUSA don’t genuinely want that. They just prefer an echo chamber that aligns with their own views.” On September 10th, coinciding with a tragic event involving Charlie Kirk, a study was released indicating that most U.S. college students, regardless of their political stance, disapprove of hosting controversial speakers on campuses.
Naomi asserted that academic institutions should allow all speakers, provided they do not promote violence. “If the objective is to discuss a topic, I believe the school shouldn’t hinder that unless violence is involved,” she stated. She emphasized the necessity of hearing multiple viewpoints during campus debates.
Naomi believes that UND actively supports free speech. “TPUSA continues to have events, demonstrating that we will not be ignored,” she mentioned. As TPUSA’s reach expands nationally, the Federalist Society at UND is seeing increased engagement this year.
When it comes to debate, Naomi doesn’t shy away from discussing sensitive issues. Although she feels some prejudice for being outspoken, she hasn’t faced public disrespect. “Respect is foundational to my approach, and I’d like it to be reciprocal,” she expressed. Sarah acknowledged that every group has its challenges, stating, “Every organization has its issues; silence isn’t the solution.”
Naomi highlighted the need for controversial discussions, especially in academia, saying, “To convince others, you must understand both sides. Charlie understood that, which is why his movement keeps growing.” Following the incident involving Charlie Kirk, students at Rutgers are urging President William F. Tate IV to support Professor Bray, who has recently left the country due to safety fears.
Bray, known for his writings including “Anti-Fascist Handbook,” has expressed he intends to relocate his family to Europe over security concerns. He mentioned that at least half of his book’s proceeds would go to the International Anti-Fascist Defense Fund.
A resolution supporting Professor Bray’s academic freedom and expression is set to be discussed by the Rutgers University Senate soon. This document urges University leadership to publically affirm Bray’s right to communicate freely, stating that political disagreements should not result in disciplinary actions unless they break laws or university policies.
