Community Garden Leaders File Federal Lawsuit
Organizers of a community garden known for its pro-Palestinian stance are claiming “severe perspective discrimination” in a new federal lawsuit. They allege that their license was revoked as a form of punishment for expressing their views.
The Sunset Community Garden, located in Central Islip, accused city officials of discrimination against their affirming stance toward queer, trans, Black, Indigenous, and people of color. Tensions have flared since the garden’s opening last September, especially among Jewish neighbors who felt alienated by the pro-Palestinian rhetoric promoted there. New members were reportedly required to pledge solidarity with marginalized communities, and a section of the garden was dedicated to “Palestine Poppies.”
Garden leaders argue that the city’s attempt to evict them, citing a breach of contract, caused them emotional distress and a sense of loss over their community space. They were advised to take legal action against the city quickly and subsequently filed a lawsuit in federal court on July 31.
The park’s management described their approach as affirming diversity, but critics, like Ridgewood resident Christina Wilkinson, believe this has led to discrimination. She expressed concern that public resources shouldn’t perpetuate discrimination against any community.
Additionally, the lawsuit mentions threats reported online, including alarming messages about violence towards garden members and damage to the property. It is also noted that there was an incident involving six individuals who threatened two immigrant stewards at the garden.
While the NYPD did not provide information regarding the report of this incident, the garden has already pursued legal action against the city twice for claims of discrimination.
In a recent change, organizer Laura Merrick renamed the garden to Jardin de Santa Cecilia in honor of a Latina Trans supporter, and two altars have been established to commemorate her.
As of now, legal representatives for both the garden and the city’s parks department have not responded to requests for further comments.
