The college football playoff committee has officially undermined its credibility with its latest rankings

Curt Cignetti responds to critics calling Indiana’s schedule “easy”: “I really don’t give a shit”

College football fans rarely agree on much. Conference loyalties, schools, regions—nearly anything can turn into an argument.

But the College Football Playoff committee seems to have united a large part of the sport’s audience in frustration. Complaints had been building since the first rankings came out, and Tuesday’s poll pushed them into the open.

The second set of rankings did little to calm things down. Several SEC teams appeared to get generous treatment, while defending national champion Indiana seemed to be judged by a different standard.

Indiana entered the first poll at No. 4, then had a bye week. Despite not playing, the Hoosiers fell five places to No. 9. Committee chair Hunter Yurachek said the timing of the bye had hurt them, especially because several ranked teams played each other. He also pointed to strong performances by UCLA, Texas, Notre Dame, Alabama and LSU.

Yurachek added that Indiana’s Big Ten opponents had all lost, which affected the team’s strength-of-schedule assessment. He also questioned the Hoosiers’ offense, saying their wins had come more because of their defense.

There’s nothing inherently wrong with winning games through defense. Still, Yurachek’s explanation seemed to establish a rule: when a team’s opponents lose, that team’s schedule can look weaker. Fair enough, perhaps. But a standard only means something if it’s applied consistently.

The committee had a chance to show that it was doing just that in its third ranking. Instead, Alabama’s position raised fresh questions.

Five of the Crimson Tide’s SEC opponents lost during the week, several of them badly, and four of those losses came at home. Kentucky had dropped two straight. Mississippi State was below .500 and had lost five consecutive games while allowing an average of 35 points per game. LSU stood at 3-4 in conference play. South Carolina had been routed by Arkansas, and Texas A&M sat well behind North Dakota State in the latest SP+ ratings.

On the face of it, Alabama’s résumé looked weaker than it had a week earlier. Yet the Tide stayed at No. 3 after a poor performance against Vanderbilt, while Indiana climbed only one spot after beating No. 18 USC.

Asked why the losses by Alabama’s opponents didn’t have the same effect as those on Indiana’s schedule, Yurachek said the impact was minimal because of the quality and strength of those teams.

That explanation is hard to square with the committee’s reasoning about Indiana. If losses by opponents matter in one case, why do they barely matter in another? South Carolina’s defeat to Arkansas, Texas A&M’s conference record, Mississippi State’s losing streak—none of that seemed to count much against Alabama. Indiana, meanwhile, was criticized for its opponents’ results and its offense.

Alabama’s own performance against Vanderbilt also seemed to receive a generous reading. Vanderbilt was 1-6 in conference play, and the Tide needed a penalty to take a 7-3 lead into halftime. Outside of three big plays, Alabama managed just 3.5 yards per play.

Yurachek praised the Tide for winning 21-6 on the road despite not playing well offensively. He also noted that teams sometimes struggle after a major win, and gave Alabama credit for avoiding a letdown after beating LSU.

That may be true, but it felt like a different kind of evaluation from the one applied to Indiana. And the gap is what has people so irritated.

The committee also placed four teams with four losses in its top 25. All four were from the SEC. Illinois, by contrast, had won four straight, including a victory over Oregon, before losing on the road to undefeated No. 4 by a single score. It didn’t receive the same consideration.

Miami, ranked No. 1, fell six places after losing by one possession on the road to a top-10 Notre Dame team. The Hurricanes were without their best player, and the game turned on a disputed incomplete-pass call. South Carolina dropped only four spots after losing to Arkansas by 28 points.

The contrast makes it seem as though SEC teams are given the benefit of the doubt simply because they play in the SEC. Wins help them, while losses somehow don’t hurt as much. That’s the impression, anyway, and the committee hasn’t offered much to dispel it.

Other questions are difficult to ignore. Why is Texas ranked behind Alabama? Why is Indiana, with one loss to a top team while its star quarterback was healthy, sitting behind a two-loss SEC team? USC lost and stayed in place. And what does Wake Forest need to do to be taken seriously?

Commentator Joel Klatt has said the committee needs its crayons taken away. It’s a sharp line, but the rankings have started to invite that kind of reaction. The explanations can feel circular: some teams are treated as strong because of their conference, and then the conference looks strong because those teams are ranked.

The committee had an opportunity to demonstrate that it was applying clear standards fairly. Instead, its explanations for Indiana and Alabama have left fans with more doubts. Maybe there’s a coherent logic behind the decisions, but at this point it’s not easy to see.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Telegram
WhatsApp

Related News