Alabama sits at 8-2, while UCLA remains unbeaten at 10-0. Yet in Tuesday night’s latest College Football Playoff rankings, Alabama was placed third and UCLA fourth, the same order as the previous week.
That gap has added to the debate over whether the committee gives the SEC an advantage over the Big Ten, Big 12 and ACC. I’m not convinced the answer is simply bias, though it’s not hard to see why people are asking questions.
The bigger problem is that fans still don’t really know what the committee values. It brings to mind the “Washington’s Dream” sketch on Saturday Night Live: when it comes to the committee’s formula, nobody knows.
The obvious solution seems straightforward: explain how the rankings are made. At the very least, the committee could identify which advanced metrics it considers when sorting the top 25.
Asked about the metrics earlier this week, CFP executive director Rich Clark said the committee hasn’t released them publicly. He added that there are so many metrics that explaining them all would be difficult, though the committee plans to consider during the offseason what it might disclose in future seasons.
The committee acknowledges that it uses metrics. So why not tell people which ones, how many, and which carry the most weight? It would also help to explain why some measures matter more than others.
Clark’s point about feasibility is hard to pin down. Maybe he meant that presenting every metric in a neat, television-friendly graphic would be impractical. Even so, with ESPN holding the playoff’s media rights through 2031, it’s reasonable to wonder how much the network influences what information reaches the public.
Nobody knows.
Strength of schedule is one factor the committee has clearly discussed. Chair Hunter Yurachek, Arkansas’s athletic director, has defended Alabama’s position by pointing to its schedule. ESPN’s Football Power Index ranks the Tide sixth in both strength of record and strength of schedule.
That may sound persuasive to some fans, but leaning on ESPN’s own figures is awkward when ESPN also owns the playoff’s media rights.
Head-to-head results are harder to read. The committee has used them in some comparisons, including Alabama’s position over Kentucky, but hasn’t appeared to apply them consistently. Alabama, for instance, is six places ahead of Tennessee despite losing to the Volunteers by 16 points. Yurachek’s explanation was that Alabama has beaten three teams ranked in the committee’s top 25.
To be fair, the schedule numbers do support Alabama in its comparison with UCLA. The Bruins rank first in strength of record but 67th in strength of schedule. Their nonconference slate included San Diego State, Cal and Nevada, all ranked near the bottom of ESPN’s FPI.
Alabama’s nonconference opponents were hardly a demanding group either. Florida State, ranked 40th, has struggled and is searching for a coach; East Carolina is 89th, and FCS Chattanooga adds little to the résumé. That schedule doesn’t seem strong enough, by itself, to settle the case for putting a two-loss Alabama ahead of UCLA.
If strength of schedule and strength of record are the committee’s preferred measures, it should just say so. Publishing a clear method would likely protect the committee from suspicion better than the current approach. As things stand, every close call can look like a favor to the SEC or to ESPN.
Or perhaps the relevant factor is conference schedule strength rather than overall schedule strength. Heather Dinich said on Tuesday’s broadcast that the committee is using a new metric this season to measure conference strength based only on league games. She suggested it could be playing a role later in the season, particularly for SEC teams.
That raises another question: why is No. 21 South Carolina still ranked after losing 34-6 to Arkansas? Before that game, Arkansas was 3-6 and had dropped four of its previous five. Is South Carolina’s place in the rankings explained by the SEC having a tougher schedule? If so, who decides how tough each conference really is?
Nobody knows. The same logic might help explain why three other four-loss teams—Oklahoma at No. 22, Florida at No. 24 and Ole Miss at No. 25—remain in the rankings.
The committee should publish its approach before the season starts. Its membership changes each year, so fans should be able to see how the group plans to build the rankings. And if the criteria shift during the season, that change should be announced along with a clear explanation.
Show your work, CFP Committee. Fans can handle it.
That much, at least, everybody knows.






