A top predator has become the focus of a renewed clash between farmers seeking more authority to protect livestock from gray wolves and conservation advocates who want the animals to retain federal safeguards. The Trump administration is weighing a decision that could influence wildlife policy across the country.
Minnesota farmer Shayne Isane says he has spent years dealing with calves killed by wolves that roam near his farm at night. He has raised livestock for nearly four decades and says he is among many producers worried about protecting their animals.
“We can walk right outside our door and hear the timber wolves howling,” Isane said. “It sends shivers down your spine when you’ve seen what they can do. They’re at the top of the food chain, and nothing hunts them.”
Isane said he has lost thousands of dollars and worries about his nearly 300 cattle, but cannot take matters into his own hands. In most circumstances, he said, farmers are prohibited from shooting wolves, even if they see one attacking livestock. The exception involves an immediate threat to human life, which he said can be difficult to establish.
President Donald Trump is considering changes to federal protections, a move that could affect states including Minnesota, Wisconsin, Michigan, California and Colorado. The Interior Department has until Dec. 3 to decide whether gray wolves and Mexican wolves have met the recovery requirements under the Endangered Species Act. If they have, the department must start a process to remove or reduce federal protections.
An Interior Department spokesperson said there was no update on the decision, but the agency recognizes the need for effective wildlife management and the problems wolf attacks can create for livestock producers.
One of Isane’s biggest losses came when three calves were killed in one night. He said wolves sometimes drag off or otherwise remove the remains, making it hard for state investigators to verify what happened.
Minnesota farmers need a carcass to confirm a suspected wolf attack and must report the loss within 48 hours to qualify for reimbursement. Losing one or two animals can cost about $3,000 each, Isane said, a significant hit to a farm’s finances.
A Minnesota Department of Agriculture spokesperson said the state reimburses verified losses at full market value and offers a grant program for wolf-related livestock losses. The department can help with prevention and compensation, the spokesperson said, but wolf management is outside its responsibility.
Isane said the damage goes beyond animals killed. Wolves can keep cattle on edge, he said, affecting their weight and overall health. State-recommended deterrents have not worked well in his experience, and he believes wolves learn to get around them.
He also disputes the idea that wolf numbers are not a growing concern. Isane said he rarely saw timber wolves during the first 30 years of his life but has seen many over the past quarter-century. “It’s gotten increasingly worse,” he said.
Minnesota’s Department of Natural Resources estimated the state had about 2,400 gray wolves in 2026, with no statistically significant change from the previous year. A department spokesperson said its research and population estimates show a stable population, not rapid or unchecked growth.
Isane supports Trump’s efforts, saying farmers have no reliable way to control the problem. White House deputy press secretary Taylor Rogers said the Biden administration’s environmental policies left ranchers exposed to predators and contributed to livestock losses. Rogers also linked those policies to the national cattle herd falling to its lowest level in 75 years and higher consumer prices, saying Trump is working to reverse them.
Shawn Regan, an editor at C3 Journal and a senior fellow at the Manhattan Institute, said states can manage wolf populations once they have recovered. The Endangered Species Act includes a process for removing species from its protections and transferring management to states, he said, adding that federal listing is not necessarily the best way to oversee recovered populations long term.
Removing federal protections for gray wolves has been part of Trump’s agenda before. During his first term, his administration ended protections across most states. Environmental groups sued, and a federal judge restored protections in 2022, with the exception of the Northern Rockies, where states retained authority. The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals is considering whether to uphold that ruling.
Some conservation groups involved in the lawsuit say Trump’s latest action could undo years of recovery work. They argue the administration should focus instead on the broader economic pressures facing farmers and ranchers.
Sara Amundson, president of Humane World Action Fund, said the administration was using wolves as a bargaining chip rather than addressing the financial challenges facing agricultural producers. Eric Clewis, a Northern Rockies representative for Defenders of Wildlife, said blaming wolves distracts from other pressures on ranching and noted that wolves account for less than 1% of livestock losses.
Collette Adkins, a senior attorney who leads the Center for Biological Diversity’s carnivore program, warned that removing federal safeguards could erase decades of recovery efforts. She said the relatively small number of livestock operators who have conflicts with wolves could improve their ability to coexist with the animals.
Environmental advocates have opposed delisting for years, arguing it could open the door to more killing, trapping and trophy hunting, while wolf populations remain short of full recovery.
Gabriella Hoffman, who directs the Center for Energy and Conservation at the Independent Women’s Forum, said delisting might prove temporary if Congress does not make the change permanent. She also raised the prospect of lawsuits blocking the policy. Hoffman recently investigated wolf attacks in Wisconsin for a conservation documentary.
Hoffman argued that delisting could help prevent wolves from becoming endangered again. She said decisions should be grounded in science, and that a management system could protect the species over time. Although livestock attacks are a serious problem for producers, she said, they can also be a sign that wolf conservation efforts have succeeded.
Michigan dairy farmer Jonathan Miller, who has raised cattle since the 1970s and now keeps a herd of about 100, said protective fencing has helped him find a workable balance with wolves. He said the barriers are effective, though moving them and keeping them electrified adds work.
Miller said wolf attacks have not caused a financial hit to his business. Earlier this month, however, two healthy sheep were killed after he failed to put up a barrier, which he described as a lapse in management.
He said losing an animal to a wolf is upsetting, but it is one of several risks farmers face. When his family lost its first calf to a wolf in the early 2000s, Miller said, it changed how they viewed the animals. The wolf, which he estimated weighed about 60 pounds, was still strong enough to drag a calf across the yard.
Miller said wolves are now seen less often in people’s yards, in part because residents have taken action themselves. He supports moving management to the states rather than leaving local people to control wolf numbers illegally.
He hopes a change in policy could help farmers and wolves live alongside one another. “I don’t want to eliminate the wolves,” Miller said. “I love to see wolves. I try to get pictures, but there has to be control.”






