President Donald Trump criticized outgoing Texas Sen. John Cornyn for blocking his nominee for a federal judgeship in Dallas, saying the senator was doing a “tremendous disservice.” Trump argued that the vacancy could otherwise be filled by someone he described as a radical left-wing extremist.
Cornyn told The Associated Press he would not return the blue slip for T. Elliot Gaiser, a senior Justice Department lawyer nominated to the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas. The Senate tradition gives a nominee’s home-state senators a chance to weigh in. Returning the slip signals support for moving forward; withholding it can stop the nomination.
Trump said people had told him Gaiser was an excellent candidate and accused Cornyn of holding up the nomination because he was upset. Trump backed Ken Paxton, Cornyn’s challenger in the Texas Republican Senate primary. He also said Cornyn had lost the primary and was taking the result badly, while adding that he considered the senator a good person.
Cornyn says nominee was not properly vetted
In a post on X, Cornyn asked why Trump waited until after the midterms to nominate someone for a seat that had been vacant since 2025. He said the White House had not consulted him and objected that Gaiser was not from Texas, had limited ties to the state, lacked trial-court experience and had not been adequately vetted for a lifetime appointment.
Cornyn said the Senate could not fulfill its constitutional duty to provide advice and consent without consultation. He added that he wanted to work with Trump to fill the vacancy while Republicans still held a Senate majority. Cornyn said he had put forward another candidate, whom a bipartisan federal judicial evaluation committee had rated highly and the White House counsel had interviewed. He said an FBI background check was the remaining step and urged the president to act quickly.
Cruz calls Cornyn’s decision frustrating
Texas Sen. Ted Cruz said he was frustrated by Cornyn’s refusal to support the nomination. Cruz described approaching Cornyn on the Senate floor and asking him to consider Gaiser’s qualifications and meet with him. According to Cruz, Cornyn declined and became angry during the exchange, shouting and swearing.
Cruz said Republicans had agreed after their midterm losses to do what they could to confirm judges before the end of the year, anticipating that Democrats would block nominations once they took office in January.
Texas had two judicial vacancies, Cruz said. A nominee for the Austin seat was on track for confirmation, but there was not enough time for a new Dallas nominee to complete the paperwork and FBI background check, a process that can take weeks. Cruz said the White House therefore proposed Gaiser, whom he described as highly qualified.
Cruz noted that Gaiser had clerked for Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito, served as Texas solicitor general and argued cases before the Supreme Court. He was also leading the Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel, which advises the president and attorney general on constitutional matters. Cruz said he had interviewed Gaiser and found him principled, intelligent and capable.
Cruz said Cornyn’s decision not to return the blue slip effectively blocked the nomination. As a result, he said, the Dallas seat would remain vacant and residents would not have a judge in that position.






