Trump cannot discourage Xi and Putin from pursuing nuclear goals with a plan made for only one of them

Trump cannot discourage Xi and Putin from pursuing nuclear goals with a plan made for only one of them

President Donald Trump’s trip to China will bring him together with two of America’s leading nuclear competitors, Russian President Vladimir Putin and Chinese President Xi Jinping. Arms control may come up in their discussions, and the United States should approach the subject with care.

The timing matters. New START, the treaty that capped U.S. and Russian nuclear arsenals, expired earlier this year. Simply reviving an agreement built for a different era would not address the challenges facing the United States now.

When the treaty was negotiated in 2010, nuclear competition centered mainly on Washington and Moscow. That picture has changed. The United States now faces two major nuclear competitors at once. China is expanding and modernizing its forces, building missile silos and developing delivery systems that pose growing risks to the United States and its allies.

A treaty that restricts U.S. and Russian weapons while leaving China’s growing arsenal untouched is no longer enough. American forces should not be shaped around assumptions that no longer fit the world we live in.

Neither Beijing nor Moscow has shown much willingness to make meaningful arms control work. China wants the standing of a great power but has resisted the obligations that might come with it, including serious nuclear talks. I encountered that reluctance during a Senate delegation visit to China earlier this year, when officials sidestepped the issue after I raised it.

Russia, for its part, has repeatedly weakened or violated arms control commitments. It also suspended participation in New START in 2023, further diminishing the agreement.

We should keep pursuing serious discussions, but it would be unrealistic to count on negotiations to resolve the threats we face. Arms control can support deterrence; it cannot take its place.

The United States needs the right number and mix of nuclear weapons to address both Russia’s advantage in nonstrategic weapons and China’s rapid buildup. In 2023, the bipartisan Congressional Commission on the Strategic Posture of the United States concluded that the force posture currently planned would not be adequate for the threats expected over the coming decade.

Deterring two nuclear powers may require a larger, more adaptable force than the one envisioned in 2010. As chair of the Senate Armed Services Committee’s Strategic Forces Subcommittee, I believe each part of the nuclear triad needs strengthening.

The bomber fleet offers a visible and flexible form of deterrence, but it is aging and under strain. With two peer nuclear adversaries, the United States needs at least 200 next-generation stealth bombers to preserve readiness and strategic flexibility. The Air Force’s original goal of at least 100 B-21s will not be enough to meet the challenge from China and Russia.

At sea, Columbia-class submarines will form the core of the U.S. second-strike capability. We need to take a hard look at whether the planned fleet is large enough for a future in which Russia and China pose threats at the same time. The country should also expand its theater nuclear forces, which could be important in managing the danger of regional nuclear conflict.

On land, the United States must replace its aging intercontinental ballistic missile system, whose origins date to the 1960s. The Sentinel program will require new infrastructure, launch facilities and command centers. Until it is ready, the country must keep the existing Minuteman III missiles operating to sustain deterrence.

U.S. deterrence also reassures allies. As nuclear risks grow in Asia, South Korea and Japan are weighing whether they need nuclear weapons of their own. A credible American defense commitment can help reassure them and discourage further proliferation.

Arms control and a strong nuclear force are connected, but negotiations should not come at the expense of investing in U.S. capabilities. Any future agreement must reflect the threats the country actually faces.

No one wants an arms race. Avoiding one, though, requires realistic arms control backed by a strong enough American deterrent that no adversary doubts the United States can defend itself and its allies.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Telegram
WhatsApp

Related News