Californians Debate Death Penalty, Billionaire Tax and Democrats’ Priorities
California’s political battles—from Gov. Gavin Newsom’s decision to commute hundreds of death sentences to voters’ rejection of a proposed billionaire tax—have drawn sharply different responses.
As Democrats prepare to take control of Congress in January, Californians also have competing ideas about what the party should tackle first. Healthcare and affordability top some lists; others want the release of the Epstein files or investigations into the Trump administration.
In Los Angeles, residents shared their views on the state’s political controversies and the issues they hope will shape the country’s next chapter.
Mixed views on Newsom’s death-row commutations
On Nov. 5, Newsom said he planned to commute all 548 of California’s death sentences to life in prison without the possibility of parole.
The state has not executed anyone since 2006, and voters have previously rejected efforts to abolish the death penalty. Newsom has argued that California cannot morally execute people on death row. Dozens of district attorneys have sued to challenge his decision.
Reactions have been divided. Some victims’ families support the commutations, while others and many prosecutors oppose them. Critics have questioned whether inmates convicted of especially brutal murders should be spared execution.
Some Los Angeles residents backed the governor’s move, saying they opposed the death penalty. Lawrence said he was comfortable with people convicted of serious crimes spending the rest of their lives in prison rather than being killed. Milan said she believed death row should be abolished altogether.
Milan also argued that people in prison should have an opportunity to rehabilitate, saying rehabilitation was a central purpose of the justice system.
Sam supported the commutations, reasoning that a life sentence without parole could be a harsher punishment than execution. Zoe was less certain, saying her view depended on the crime. She thought lifelong imprisonment might be worse than death and said she would prefer that those convicted suffer for the rest of their lives.
Other residents defended capital punishment for people convicted of serious crimes, including murder. Dave, from Santa Monica, said he supported the death penalty. David said California should follow federal standards and that execution may be appropriate when someone is proven guilty of murder beyond a reasonable doubt.
What Californians want Congress to address
California helped fuel Democrats’ gains in the 2026 midterms. The party won five House seats previously held by Republicans in the state, contributing to its takeover of Congress.
The gains followed California voters’ approval of Proposition 50 in 2025. The measure redrew congressional districts to favor Democrats in response to Republican-backed redistricting efforts in Texas.
Asked what the new Democratic majority should focus on, Sam named the Epstein files, saying he was frustrated that the issue had remained unresolved. He also criticized what he saw as an unfair tax system that benefits wealthy people.
Zoe said Democrats should work to stop military actions that lack congressional approval, including U.S. involvement in the war in Iran. She objected to wars and the bombing of people.
Healthcare was another leading concern. David, who said he voted for left-leaning candidates, wanted healthcare to be the party’s top priority. Lawrence called for healthcare coverage for everyone and suggested raising taxes on the wealthiest people to pay for it.
Some residents urged Democrats to work with Republicans rather than deepen partisan divisions. Milan said she hoped the party would move beyond the split between the far left and far right. Dave wanted Democrats to cooperate with Republicans and the president, though he did not expect that to happen.
Californians split over rejected billionaire tax
Proposition 40, one of the most closely watched measures on California’s 2026 midterm ballot, proposed a one-time 5% tax on the state’s billionaires. It was intended to raise $100 billion for healthcare and education.
Voters rejected the measure, with about 53% opposed and 47% in favor. The result was a setback for progressives who had supported taxing the state’s wealthiest residents.
Technology executives spent millions of dollars to oppose the proposal. Google co-founder Sergey Brin contributed more than $100 million to political action committees campaigning against it. Newsom also opposed the tax and urged voters to reject it.
Some Los Angeles residents were surprised the proposal failed in a state where Democrats hold a strong advantage. Milan suggested that messaging against the measure had influenced voters. Lawrence said he was startled it did not pass, given that billionaires make up a very small share of California’s population.
Sam called the outcome frustrating, arguing that wealthy people should pay more while middle- and lower-income residents shoulder their own tax bills. He said the state’s wealth gap was enormous.
Others were glad the proposal failed. Zoe said she did not want billionaires to leave California. Dave argued that keeping them in the state was important to its economy, adding that wealthy residents already pay a large share of taxes.
Residents weigh investigations against everyday concerns
Democrats are expected to pursue investigations into President Donald Trump, members of his Cabinet and business associates after taking control of Congress in January.
Democratic leaders in the House and Senate have discussed investigations, hearings and possible impeachment proceedings involving Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick, Secretary of State Marco Rubio, White House chief of staff Stephen Miller and border czar Tom Homan.
Republicans have called the planned actions politically motivated. The administration has also signaled it will push back against congressional investigations.
Asked whether Democrats should focus on affordability and other issues affecting Americans or investigate the Trump administration, Lawrence said they could do both. Zoe said investigations were worthwhile if they did not distract from work that directly helps people.
Several residents said everyday concerns should come first, while also acknowledging the need to hold the administration accountable. David said both healthcare and accountability mattered, though he believed most people were more concerned about healthcare.
Milan said the daily needs of ordinary people should carry more weight than a prolonged political fight. Still, she said, the Trump administration should be held accountable, even if doing so takes considerable time and back-and-forth.




