President Donald Trump's recent proposal to eliminate federal income taxes on social security benefits would benefit the old millennials in their 40s, among the highest income groups.
new Report The budget model of nonpartisan research group Penn Wharton found that this particular group of millennials shows a marked increase in lifelong welfare.
Why is it important?
Trump's tax proposal aims to reduce financial pressure on older adults by strengthening social security checks. However, while we promise short-term benefits to some, the Penn Wharton Budget Model Report highlights long-term financial risks.
The policy not only promotes the depletion of the Social Security Trust Fund for two years, but also supports the wealthier older people at the expense of younger and future generations.
read more: Donald Trump gets bad news about his Social Security Tax Plan
Andrew Harnik/Getty Images
What do you know
Social Security, a rough lifeline 68 million Americans now contain taxes that contribute billions of dollars in federal revenue each year. These taxes are tiered based on combined income levels.
Trump's proposal would eliminate federal income taxes on social security benefits, but Penn Wharton's budget model report says not all generations will flourish.
In particular, the Millennials report found that these tax exclusions are the most profitable for older millennials in their 40s in their income band, worth a one-time payment of $12,400. This suggests an increase in lifelong welfare.
“Tax cuts benefit mostly high-income people,” said Kent Smetter, chairman of the University of Pennsylvania Wharton School. Newsweek.
Of all generations, those with a close resignation will benefit the most. Specifically, he is 70 years old, the percentile of income of 80 to 100. These individuals could amount to substantial lifetime welfare benefits, or up to $43,600.
Young individuals and future generations will carry out the worst under proposed policy changes. The model predicts that fetuses representing future generations could face the most significant welfare losses in the range of $11,700 to $22,000.
Maria Fries, a senior social security prediction by the National Committee, to maintain social security and Medicare, is Newsweek Fern with analysis.
“These older adults (including millennials) don't have time to increase their private savings in the face of inevitable social security cuts, making the impact more dramatic than current retirees and those close to retirement ages. I think it will be. The Social Security Trust Fund will run out, causing an estimated automatic 17% profit cut,” Freeze said.
She noted that this assumes that Congress will not intervene to increase the financial stability of Social Security.
“Young people, in theory, will have more time to adjust their retirement savings habits so they can absorb their retirement benefits,” she added.
What people are saying
Kent Smetters, chairman of the University of Pennsylvania Wharton School, Newsweek: “Middle-aged and older people get to receive benefits, but don’t need to raise a lot of that because younger people don’t get future taxable income.
Maria Fries, a senior social security prediction by the National Committee, to maintain social security and Medicare, is Newsweek: “I believe his plan will speed up the trust fund's drain date by two years, so I believe it is inherently dangerous for the program and beneficiaries. I've done it for almost 90 years.
I like Rep. John Larson's Social Security 2100 Act. This cuts tax on benefits, but unlike Trump's proposal, it pays by bringing more income to the program… Benefits that help you maintain your loan without paying Social Security solvents Trump's proposal to eliminate taxes “breaks his promise to not touch Social Security.”
Nancy Altman, president of Social Security, said Kiplinger: “He's talking about removing taxation, which increases profits, but will significantly reduce the very profits that are subject to taxation.”
Sen. Roger Marshall, a Kansas Republican, said in a news release: “After four years of record inflation, current taxes on social security are devastating for American retirees… By cutting taxes on social security, the bill will result in the bill being devastating for seniors in America. It ensures that you can maintain and correct your hard-earned money. A fundamental flaw in the tax system.”
What will happen next
Trump's proposal to eliminate federal income taxes on social security benefits could have significant benefits for old and wealthy millennials, younger generations and future beneficiaries, but the sustainability and equity of the social security system I am questioning the following.
