Trump-Xi clash brings back Clinton’s 25-year-old China “mistake” as a longtime senator demands it be reversed

Trump-Xi clash brings back Clinton’s 25-year-old China “mistake” as a longtime senator demands it be reversed

Former U.S. ambassador Sam Brownback wants Washington to reconsider China’s permanent normal trade relations status, a policy dating back more than two decades. He argues the United States should rethink its economic ties with Beijing as President Donald Trump prepares to meet Chinese President Xi Jinping.

“We should correct the decision we made 25 years ago,” Brownback said, arguing that China poses a threat to the United States and fails to protect human rights.

Trump is traveling to China this week for his third meeting with Xi this year. The leaders are scheduled to meet Thursday in Shenzhen, followed by a trilateral meeting with Russian President Vladimir Putin. Trade tensions and U.S. reliance on Chinese supplies are among the issues hanging over the talks.

Brownback, who served as ambassador-at-large for international religious freedom during Trump’s first administration, said Trump’s current approach is tactically sound, but the United States is in a difficult position.

President Bill Clinton signed legislation authorizing permanent normal trade relations with China in 2000. President George W. Bush granted the status in December 2001, after China joined the World Trade Organization.

Taking that status away would generally mean higher tariffs on Chinese imports. It would not, by itself, end trade between the two countries. Brownback said reducing U.S. dependence on China and reshaping trade ties would take years, not happen through an immediate break.

He called for an orderly effort to reconsider the trade policy while pressing Beijing on human rights and religious freedom. One option, he said, could be a “Helsinki Accords 2.0,” modeled on the 1975 Cold War agreement that brought human rights into wider negotiations involving the United States, its European allies and the Soviet Union.

Such an agreement could create room for talks on trade and religious freedom, Brownback said, while making clear that continued abuses could put normal trade relations at risk. He urged Trump to raise the treatment of Christians and other religious groups directly with Xi.

The U.S. Department of Labor estimated in 2022 that 100,000 Uyghurs and other ethnic minority former detainees in China may have been subjected to forced labor after being held in re-education camps.

“We can’t keep trading with you if this continues, especially when people of faith, including Christians, are being targeted,” Brownback said.

For now, he said, simply preventing the relationship from deteriorating further would count as progress while the United States works to reduce its reliance on China for goods such as rare-earth minerals and pharmaceutical supplies.

Brownback also described religious freedom as a strategic pressure point for China’s Communist leadership, which he said sees independent religious institutions as a challenge to its authority. “They have a larger navy than we do, but religious freedom worries them more than our aircraft carriers or missiles,” he said.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Telegram
WhatsApp

Related News