President Donald Trump’s suggestion in a “60 Minutes” interview that he might work with Democrats on a deal allowing some undocumented immigrants to gain legal status prompted debate among immigration specialists over what such an agreement could mean.
The interview aired days after Republicans suffered heavy losses in the midterm elections, renewing questions about whether Trump might soften his approach. He later rejected the idea of amnesty, saying there would be none and insisting his immigration policy had not changed.
Trump has not described a specific plan. But his remarks have raised concerns and questions about the rule of law, assimilation and the potential costs to taxpayers.
Steven Camarota, research director at the Center for Immigration Studies, said granting legal status to a large group of people who entered or remained in the country unlawfully could weaken respect for immigration laws.
He also questioned whether such a policy would seem fair to people who followed the rules. Someone who overstayed a visa, for example, should not necessarily be rewarded with citizenship, he argued, particularly when many others left the country after their visas expired.
Laura Collins, who directs immigration policy at the George W. Bush Presidential Center, said those concerns deserve consideration. But she argued that the immigration system itself is not working as intended: employers seek workers, while the legal system limits the flow of labor.
In her view, the country faces a choice between preventing undocumented immigrants from staying and contributing to the economy, or allowing some to remain through a process that requires them to make amends.
Collins noted that past legalization proposals have included requirements such as paying back taxes, passing background checks and paying fees or fines. Camarota questioned whether a future agreement would make those payments a firm condition of receiving citizenship.
Camarota also said immigration limits are meant, in part, to keep the number of newcomers from exceeding communities’ ability to support assimilation. He argued that large-scale legalization could weaken those limits and reduce the incentive to enforce them.
Collins pointed to the 2022 book “Streets of Gold: America’s Untold Story of Immigrant Success,” which compared present-day immigrants with earlier generations. The book found that immigrants today are integrating at roughly similar rates, she said. About 15% of the U.S. population is foreign-born, a share comparable to historic highs in the late 19th and early 20th centuries.
Collins added that having the ability to work legally can help people integrate. She said the country has a strong record of welcoming newcomers and turning them into Americans, though she understands why some people worry about the pace of change. In her view, the available data does not support those concerns.
Camarota estimated that households headed by undocumented immigrants receive about $50 billion a year in government benefits, often through programs used by their U.S.-born children. He cited Medicaid, Supplemental Security Income, Temporary Assistance for Needy Families and free school lunches. Undocumented immigrants themselves are generally barred from many federal welfare programs.
He said the issue was not that immigrants were unwilling to work, but that many have limited formal education. Legal status, he argued, would not change the population’s overall education levels, and lower-income workers may pay too little in taxes to cover the public services they use.
Camarota also noted that many undocumented immigrants already pay taxes, with more than half believed to work on the books. Legalization, he said, would not necessarily bring a major tax benefit and could make more people eligible for welfare programs.
Collins agreed that many immigrants have limited education but said that does not mean they are working at the level their abilities would allow. She cited a 2013 Congressional Budget Office analysis of the Gang of Eight immigration bill, S. 744, which projected that the legislation would raise federal revenue and reduce deficits by about $158 billion over 10 years, despite higher spending on benefits.
Legal work authorization could also allow some immigrants to earn higher wages or move into different jobs, Collins said, increasing their tax contributions and giving them a chance to reach their potential.
Mark Krikorian, who leads the Center for Immigration Studies, said an amnesty deal was unlikely, making much of the debate hypothetical. He said the chances of an agreement were close to zero, including after the next Congress takes office.
Krikorian argued that Republicans have little leverage because Democrats would be unlikely to accept tighter immigration restrictions in exchange for legalization. He pointed to proposals involving people covered by DACA, a program that offers temporary protection from deportation to some immigrants brought to the country as children.
Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin has recently raised the possibility of a compromise that could give DACA recipients permanent legal status. Krikorian argued that they already have a form of protection, and that moving them to green cards would amount to expanding it without securing meaningful concessions from Democrats.
The first Trump administration had considered using DACA recipients as part of a broader deal to win stricter immigration measures, Krikorian said. But he doubted Democrats would agree to restrictions in exchange for granting recipients green cards.
He also warned that permanent residency could have wider effects. Green-card holders may petition for certain relatives, and after five years they can apply for citizenship. Once naturalized, they can petition for their parents, who are not subject to numerical limits, although other restrictions may still apply to some family members.
During the “60 Minutes” interview, Trump discussed the possibility of allowing some undocumented workers in fields such as hospitality and landscaping to remain in the country. He said it was difficult to see workers, including hotel cleaners and waitresses, being removed from the country, and criticized people he described as far-right for supporting deportations regardless of whether someone was employed.
The White House said Trump’s immigration policy had not changed. Spokeswoman Lauren Bis urged Democrats to work with the president to secure the border, deport dangerous criminal immigrants and stop drug trafficking. She said the administration’s approach had produced what it considers the most secure border in U.S. history.
Bis added that Democrats would be acting against the interests of Americans if they pursued what she called open-border and mass-amnesty policies. The Department of Homeland Security did not respond to a request for comment.






