A lot of Christians find themselves puzzled by the first miracle of Jesus described in the book of John, where he turns water into wine at a wedding following his mother’s request. It raises a question: If Christians are advised to avoid drunkenness, why would Jesus create more wine, potentially increasing the chance of intoxication?
Some see this as a contradiction.
In a recent episode of “The Embarrassment,” Jace, Al Robertson, and Zach Dasher tackled this inquiry.
“The Bible doesn’t label alcohol as inherently bad, but being drunk is always frowned upon,” Jace explains.
To clarify God’s teachings about drunkards, he references Ephesians 5:18, which warns, “Do not get drunk with wine; it leads to debauchery; instead, be filled with the Spirit.” He also points to Galatians 5:22, where “self-control,” the opposite of drunkenness, is mentioned as a fruit of the Spirit.
Yet, Jace argues that while these statements hold truth, “they don’t directly apply to John 2.”
According to him, Jesus turning water into wine is a revelation of his identity and purpose.
“Transforming water into wine leads to the new wine that Jesus speaks of bringing… It’s no coincidence that he performs this miracle at a wedding, as we are considered the bride of Christ,” he notes.
He adds that the gathering highlights the notion that “we are part of the ultimate celebration hosted by Jesus.”
Moreover, in John 2, Jesus illustrates that true miraculous changes require his divine intervention. Through an effortless act—simply turning water into wine—he sends a message: “If you’re seeking transformation, I’m the one to turn to,” Jace emphasizes.
Al contributes by pointing out Mary’s faith in this narrative.
“Her belief in him is powerful. She turns to him with the request, ‘Please help with the wine situation,’ showing incredible faith in that moment,” he remarks.
For many Christians, especially newer ones, John 2 becomes a topic of debate concerning its implications on alcohol, shifting the focus toward a larger understanding of who Jesus is and his actions.
Nevertheless, it’s crucial to heed God’s warnings against drunkenness.
Zach suggests that individuals with a history of alcohol abuse should likely abstain completely, adding, “I wouldn’t drink around anyone I know struggles with it.”
“The more you get to know Jesus and what he offers, the more you realize it’s not about ‘doing’ or ‘not doing’ but living in faith,” Al concludes.
For more insights from the panel, you can watch the full episode.
