Supporters of the strikes on Iran have sharply criticized Vice President JD Vance. Some seem irritated by his warnings against “forever wars,” while others have blamed his earlier efforts to secure peace for Republicans’ historic midterm losses.
Vance, a Marine Corps veteran who served in Iraq, said in a Monday interview that the United States had achieved “an extraordinary amount” in Iran. Still, he argued, some people appear to want the conflict to continue without end.
He said President Donald Trump has several ways to bring the fighting to a close, but that some will keep demanding more. Vance added that Trump would not allow the conflict to become another forever war, saying the administration had promised Americans to avoid that kind of prolonged engagement.
Vance’s comments drew a wave of criticism. So did his post-election assessment that the war was the reason Republicans lost. Fox News host Brian Kilmeade, who has supported past U.S. conflicts in the Middle East, objected to both remarks.
On his podcast Wednesday, Kilmeade called Vance’s interview comments “aggravating” and said he should never have become vice president. He argued that he had never met anyone calling for an endless war, and dismissed Vance’s warning as a straw-man argument.
“Forever war” does not generally mean a conflict that literally never ends. The phrase is commonly used for long, costly military campaigns—such as the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan—where the goals or conditions for success can remain unclear or shift over time.
The strikes on Iran began on February 28, nine months ago, and some prominent supporters of military action have argued that the campaign should continue.
Former Vice President Mike Pence recently told the Washington Examiner that, with the midterms over, Trump should unleash U.S. and Israeli forces to finish the job. Pence rejected Vance’s claim that the Iran conflict contributed to the Republican losses, arguing instead that the problem was that the fighting stopped.
Pence also criticized the peace agreement Trump signed in June, calling it appeasement and saying it was not worth the paper it was printed on. He implied that Vance bore responsibility for the deal.
Arkansas Senator Tom Cotton has likewise argued against ending the military operation. In a Wednesday post, he accused Democrats of wanting to surrender to Iran and let terrorists control the Strait of Hormuz. The United States needs a strategy for victory, he said, rather than an exit strategy.
Cotton also condemned the June memorandum of understanding, calling it ill-advised and naive. He suggested the agreement may have prolonged the conflict, and argued that it gave Democrats grounds to describe the war as a forever war.
After Vance’s interview, Babylon Bee CEO Seth Dillon asked who, specifically, was calling for the conflict to continue forever. Marc Thiessen, a former speechwriter for President George W. Bush, replied that there was no one.
Thiessen has previously argued that the United States faced no downside from striking Iran. In a column last Thursday, he said operations should continue until total victory is achieved, writing that the Iranian regime might collapse before Trump leaves office—or that it could take longer.
Thiessen did not explain what he meant by “longer.” Trump’s second term has more than two years remaining.
In a recent Emerson College poll of possible Republican candidates for president in 2028, Vance trailed Secretary of State Marco Rubio by 16 points. Rubio has described the war as necessary. Vance, however, remains popular among Republicans: an Economist/YouGov poll conducted November 9–11 found him leading the field with 40%, compared with Rubio’s 33%.

