Are American Women Facing a Psychological Crisis Amid Political Turmoil?
There seems to be a growing concern that American women might be experiencing an intensified psychological crisis due to the current political climate. Blaze TV host Allie Beth Stuckey suggests that much of this activism isn’t representative of most women, who typically align more with conservative or moderate views. Instead, she points to a smaller but passionate group pushing extreme progressive ideals.
A case in point is Renee Nicole Good, identified as a victim in a recent ICE shooting in Minneapolis. Good has become somewhat of a figure in liberal media, often seen as emblematic of women undergoing mental health struggles. “She fits the stereotype of a liberal white woman,” Stuckey comments. But is this portrayal valid for all older white women? Her answer is ambiguous. She notes that while 36% of white women are conservative, a significant chunk does not identify as liberal. Specifically, 33% categorize themselves as moderates and 28% as liberals.
Despite these statistics, Stuckey contends that women identifying as liberal often exhibit intense behavior. “I think there’s a connection to what’s sometimes called misplaced parenting, which goes beyond just white women. It relates to women as a whole,” she elaborates.
Misplaced parenting occurs when maternal instincts are redirected—toward pets, politics, or professions—rather than children. “This inner discord can lead to bitterness and emotional instability, particularly when it comes to social justice issues,” she explains.
Stuckey adds that actions and causes become like children to these women, engendering intense attachment. For instance, she cites situations where an illegal immigrant or someone struggling with gender identity is viewed as a ‘child’ to protect. “This shift in focus is driven by what I term toxic empathy,” she states, suggesting that heightened empathy can lead to radicalization.
Interestingly, she observes that extremely empathetic individuals may become unkind toward those they view as oppressors. Once someone is classified as a victim, their struggles overshadow everything else. Stuckey believes this dynamic explains the fierce loyalty some women show toward figures like Good, while often being vocal opponents against others—even celebrating their misfortunes on social media.
In her view, Good embodies a protective role for marginalized groups, where perceived oppressors become adversaries, revealing a cruelty that’s startling.
