Changing Face of Leading Men in Hollywood

Vanity Fair’s recent “Hollywood Issues” edition announces the decline of the classic, hypermasculine movie star, highlighting how contemporary actors are embracing a fresh narrative of “vulnerability” and “accessibility.”

The annual cover story, titled “2026 Hollywood Questions: Ask the Boys!” showcases prominent male actors such as Glen Powell, Andrew Garfield, Jonathan Bailey, Paul Mescal, Michael B. Jordan, and Austin Butler. This feature reflects a significant cultural shift away from traditional male archetypes in the film industry.

“In Hollywood’s Golden Age, studios transformed everyday men into modern gods, concealing their imperfections,” writes author Ottessa Moshfegh in the article.

The piece asserts that the era of the isolated matinee idol has concluded, paving the way for a new breed of actors who are relatable and authentic. Moshfegh notes, “Although they remain fantasy figures, they are akin to boyfriends: approachable, kind, vulnerable, and very human.”

The article points out that this new wave of male stars, often labeled as “internet boyfriends,” is purposefully designed to be more relatable and emotionally accessible. Iconic figures like Tom Cruise and Marlon Brando have been succeeded by individuals who openly share their feelings and life experiences on social media.

“We want to connect with them, understand their emotions, and what drives them,” Moshfegh writes, adding that fans follow their playlists, break-up sagas, and skincare routines.

Hollywood’s portrayal of masculinity is evolving into something “expressive and safe.” The article states, “‘Great energy’ no longer connotes dominance; instead, it emphasizes presence, integrity, and authenticity.”

However, not everyone sees this shift positively. Anthony Mackie, known as Marvel’s new Captain America, criticizes the change, asserting that traditional masculinity remains valuable. He commented, “For the past two decades, we’ve witnessed the decline of the American man,” during a discussion on the “Pivot Podcast.”

Mackie continues, “For some reason, masculinity has been suppressed in our homes and communities, and I intend to raise my sons to embody traditional manhood.” While opinions on Hollywood’s evolving male figures differ, Vanity Fair’s coverage suggests that this transition is now a permanent aspect of the industry.