Victor Davis Hanson Challenges Elizabeth Warren’s Claims on Illegal Immigration

In the latest episode of “Victor Davis Hanson: In His Own Words,” Hanson, alongside Jack Fowler, addressed Senator Elizabeth Warren’s assertion that illegal immigrants do not receive federal health insurance.

Hanson began by pointing out that estimates of illegal immigration vary widely. Citing a 2019 Yale study, he contended that rather than just 6 to 7 million as some claim, there could be up to 12 million undocumented individuals in the country. This estimation, he believes, could even be as high as 21 million, given that the numbers are often underestimated.

He continued, elaborating that with a foreign-born population of about 53 million in the U.S., it wouldn’t be surprising if 35 million were here illegally. He urged Warren to visit emergency rooms in California, where he has noticed the overwhelming presence of non-English speakers, hinting at the reality that many of these individuals rely on government programs for healthcare.

According to him, when people walk into these emergency rooms—regardless of their legal status—they are treated. He expressed frustration that individuals might evaluate these situations based solely on stipulations rather than acknowledging the practical realities at play.

Fowler chimed in to add that the issue isn’t just limited to healthcare but extends to various forms of government assistance, including Social Security disability. This aspect seemed to resonate with Hanson, who recounted a story about an aunt that struggled significantly due to polio, illustrating how challenging it can be to receive disability support for those truly in need versus those who might exploit the system.

He reflected on how societal attitudes toward support programs have shifted over time. He mentioned former President John F. Kennedy’s ethos of civic duty, suggesting that the current landscape feels devoid of that spirit, especially amidst the recent waves of immigration.

Hanson concluded by emphasizing the importance of integrating newcomers into American culture. He argued that on-the-ground efforts, like English lessons, are crucial but sadly lacking. The prevailing narrative, he believes, focuses more on victimization rather than fostering a sense of belonging and responsibility within newly arrived individuals.