A state court judge on Monday declared Georgia's Infant Fairness and Equality (LIFE) Act unconstitutional. 2019 law This bans abortions when a fetal heartbeat can be detected (usually around the sixth week of pregnancy) unless there is a “medical emergency”.
In signing the bill, Gov. Brian Kemp (R) characterized it as “a declaration that all lives have value, all lives matter, and all lives deserve protection.” I attached it. Fulton County Superior Court Judge Robert C.J. McBurney agreed with Kemp's opinion that all life deserves protection. The difference is that he also includes the lives of women and girls.
mcburnies 26 page judgment Thus destroying Justice Samuel Alito's argument for the majority in Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Authority, overturning Roe v. Wade and effectively removing women's interests from the abortion equation under the Fourteenth Amendment. Deleted. He also exposed the irony that the Dobbs majority's claims, parroted by former President Donald Trump during his campaign, were simply channeling the abortion issue.return to state”
McBurney's decision applied the Georgia Constitution, rather than the federal constitution currently controlled by Dobbs, to invalidate the state law. But his analysis of the Georgia Constitution is equally applicable to the federal Constitution.
Under Roe, legislative restrictions on abortion were imposed through a classic constitutional balancing test that placed women's constitutional interests on one side and the state's interests on the other. Roe's majority opinion explains women's interests—which, in theory, the state should also consider—as follows:
“Even in the early stages of pregnancy, specific and direct medically diagnosable harm may be involved: giving birth, or having an additional child, can impose a miserable life and future on the woman. Emotional harm may be imminent. Parenting can take its toll on mental and physical health. There is also the psychological and other suffering associated with an unwanted child. There is also the issue of bringing into the family a child who is already unable to care for them due to personal reasons.
Alito completely ignores this list, instead focusing exclusively on the state's interest in protecting “'fetal life' and what is called 'fetus' in the laws before us today.” defended.
Mr. McBurney Republican appointee“Whether you claim it as freedom or privacy (or equal protection), this debate is fundamentally about the scope of a woman's right to control her body and what happens within it. ” And under Georgia law, “the basic rule is clear: a legally competent person has absolute authority over her own body and what she does in terms of health, hygiene, etc. This constraint on state power, he reasoned, could lead people to “gluttony and self-deprivation.'' They are “free to tattoo or pierce every square inch of their skin” and “generally” can receive or refuse medical care, whether elective or mandatory. ”.
Governor McBurney acknowledged that Georgia recognizes competing interests in the life of a fetus, but said that anyone who engages in a “pregnancy caused by cardiac activity beyond the fetal stage” or facilitates an abortion. He rejected the state's argument that he could be charged with a felony under the Georgia Constitution. Until a fetus is viable, that is, able to live outside its mother and enjoy the protection of the state, “in this vast world, by choice or by compulsion of law, The only person who can maintain a pregnancy is the pregnant woman. Mother herself. “Unlike a newborn baby or a catatonic elderly person, our society should and does support families and friends when they withdraw from their expected role as caregivers. However, in the case of a non-viable fetus, there is no one else who can assume the role of the woman.'' McBurney reached this conclusion after an evidentiary trial.
Regarding the argument that it is the state's responsibility, not the judge's, to make this calculation, McBurney writes: “Women are not part of collectively owned community property, the disposition of which cannot be determined by majority vote.'' And he somewhat bravely stated: “Laws like the LIFE Act are typically promoted and defended by men, and their effectiveness is only Women, and given the socio-economic and demographic evidence presented at trial, are primarily poor women, primarily black and brown women in Georgia, who give birth to pregnancies through forced labor, or government orders. are forced to engage in up to ”
Since Georgia enacted a six-week pregnancy ban, at least two women She died after attempting to legally terminate her pregnancy. Amber Nicole Thurman, 28, mother of a 6-year-old boy, was on medication to abort her early pregnancy, but the miscarriage resulted in her uterus not being fully expelled. Ta. She went to Piedmont Henry Hospital for a routine dilation and curettage procedure, or D&C, but doctors I waited for 20 hours Applying the exception before invoking the law's exception for medical emergencies could result in a felony conviction if assessed incorrectly. Meanwhile, her organs began to fail. When doctors finally decided on surgery, she died from a septic infection.
When Candy Miller, a 41-year-old mother of three with lupus, diabetes and high blood pressure, became unintentionally pregnant in the fall of 2022, she ordered abortion pills online. Again, the medication was not effective in completely curing the miscarriage. After suffering for days, her husband found her dead in her bed, her 3-year-old daughter by her side. The family told the coroner that Miller was reluctant to seek medical care “due to current laws regarding pregnancy and abortion.”
Both women's deaths were preventable, and both women were Black.
Voters, come November. in 10 states Under the state constitution, they will have the opportunity to decide whether to protect access to abortion, at least until viability. Nebraska would face competing options between largely protecting abortion and banning it. In all states except Maryland and New York (including conservative states such as Arizona and Florida), abortion protections were citizen-initiated rather than proposed by state legislatures. This speaks volumes about bringing abortion “back to the states.”
Voters should read McBurney's decision and vote as if their lives, or the lives of the women and girls they care about, depend on it. Because they are.
kimberly wale I'm the author of a new book “Pardon Power: How the Pardon System Works and Why”
