Young men are often told that masculinity itself is a problem, and that ambition, aggression, and the urge to protect and provide are traits they should set aside. A viral debate about Anakin Skywalker has pushed back against that idea, with BlazeTV host Nick Freitas arguing that the discussion is more complicated than it first appears.
Some people say young men identify with Anakin because he wants a wife and family, and hopes to be a hero who can repair what has gone wrong. Freitas says that explanation gets at something real. In a healthy society, he argues, young men often admire heroes who stand up against difficult odds and fight for the people and places they love.
Such a figure might win, or might fall, Freitas says. Either way, he can still be someone worth following.
Freitas says young men are increasingly encouraged to reject the qualities that might inspire that kind of heroism. They’re told that masculine traits and the passions associated with being a man are harmful, and that they should become more feminized instead.
But he cautions against treating that frustration as a reason to approve of Anakin’s decision to join the dark side. Palpatine, who persuades him, was not offering a genuine answer to his concerns, Freitas says; he was manipulating Anakin for his own purposes.
Freitas describes the Jedi philosophy as contradictory: it portrays personal desires as bad, while suggesting that giving them up for the system is virtuous because the system represents good. The Empire, by contrast, urges Anakin to use his power to impose order and defeat his enemies without mercy.
Freitas points to Anakin’s conversation with Padme, in which he suggests that people should come together, discuss problems, and decide what is best for everyone. Padme replies that this is already how their system is meant to work; the difficulty is that people disagree. Anakin’s answer, that they should be made to agree, sounds to Freitas like dictatorship.
He warns that the same logic can be dangerous when the people in power claim they know what is best for everyone. Freitas argues that, in his view, progressive policies around gender identity could lead to people being compelled to comply, including parents who disagree with decisions involving their children in Massachusetts.
For Freitas, the Jedi being wrong does not make the Empire right. The harder question, he says, is where to find a balance between the two.






