US Ambassador Mike Huckabee recently voiced unusual criticism of Israel following violent acts by a small faction of Jewish extremists against Teibe, a Palestinian Christian village in Samaria.
Last week, Huckabee condemned the killing of Palestinian-American Christians described as “terrorists.” On Saturday, he visited Teibe to express solidarity with its residents.
Huckabee’s critique comes from a unique position. He has been a strong Israel supporter, once arguing that all of Judea and Samaria, potentially including Teibe, should be under Israeli control.
His critique isn’t directed at those who oppose Israel or want it to relinquish land—it’s more of a frank concern that can only be raised by a true friend.
Generally, Israelis have a favorable view of Christians and appreciate their support. Many settlers in conflict zones on the West Bank actually prefer coexistence with their Palestinian neighbors, whether they are Christians or Muslims.
Local priest Father Jack Novel, who fled from the Merkite Catholic Church in Greece, mentioned that the media had reported a previously good relationship with local Jewish settlers.
The issue appears to stem from a particular group of settlers. Although media coverage is still sparse, this situation feels familiar to many Israelis.
For years, a small contingent of settlers, often referred to as “hilltop youths,” has operated outside Israeli laws, attempting to oust local Palestinians and assert their control over the land. They seem unafraid of Israeli police or military forces.
Israel has struggled with this situation for numerous reasons, especially the ongoing conflict with Palestinians.
It’s politically challenging for Israeli governments to defend Palestinians or confront fellow Jews, particularly when Palestinian violence against Jews is an ongoing issue. This is especially true for the government led by Netanyahu and his right-wing allies.
In the past, Israel has dealt with settler extremism, but also encountered peaceful settlers who were removed from certain Gaza communities in 2005—a painful memory, particularly since it led to Hamas taking control and resulting in significant turmoil.
Jewish extremists pose a real danger to Israel. They not only damage the image of the state among Christians but also challenge the rule of law within Israel.
In fact, tensions between secular and religious Jews over issues like military conscription represent a significant threat to Israel’s unity and security.
Huckabee understands that Israel holds a strong affection for Christians, and he wields considerable moral authority as a US supporter of Israel against threats like Iran.
This situation provides Huckabee with the diplomatic leeway to offer critique, urging Israel to uphold its own laws and values.
By criticizing Israel, Huckabee also offers political cover for right-wing critics concerning actions against extremist settlers and might support Israel in various ways.
Firstly, he indicates that Jerusalem doesn’t require another Palestinian enclave; his visit shows that engaging Palestinians can occur without the need to further partition the capital.
Secondly, Huckabee confirmed the stance of President Donald Trump regarding Israel, which goes against criticisms from anti-Israel Democrats. At his Senate confirmation hearing, Huckabee claimed to represent “Presidential Priorities,” signifying a commitment that aligns with his criticisms.
There may be no contradiction for Huckabee in advocating for Palestinian Christians while also challenging Israel. This also helps him demonstrate to other Christians that supporting Israel doesn’t mean neglecting Christian duties or concerns.
Above all, Huckabee’s critique opens a dialogue for Israel to consider.
When he first took office, Huckabee cited the Prophet Isaiah as his guiding inspiration. Isaiah forecast Israel’s redemption while also offering critiques to its leaders when they strayed. Huckabee’s approach mirrors this, providing insights that only a genuine supporter of Israel could convey.
