Reaction to Minneapolis School Shooting

This week, California Governor Gavin Newsom joined other Democratic leaders in response to a tragic shooting at a Catholic school in Minneapolis. He took a moment to express skepticism about the power of prayer, pointing out that the children were praying when they were shot.

On a post on X, Newsom reacted to White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt’s comment that “prayers are at work,” stating, “The kids were literally praying when they were shot,” which seemed to suggest a lack of effectiveness in those prayers.

Democratic leaders have consistently criticized the approach of offering “thoughts and prayers” to victims and their families after mass shootings. They argue that immediate political action, especially around gun control, is essential. There has been considerable frustration expressed regarding the phrase “thoughts and prayers,” seen by many as an inadequate response to such tragedies.

In light of the Minneapolis incident, where two children lost their lives and 17 others were injured, some Democrats highlighted the fact that the children were in morning mass as evidence that prayers didn’t work.

Batya Unger Sargon, who has changed her political views, cautioned against denouncing the victims in such situations.

Historically, Newsom has faced criticism for his stance on religious freedoms. During the pandemic, he imposed restrictions on religious gatherings, which were later deemed unconstitutional by the U.S. Supreme Court. Moreover, he has actively promoted abortion access in California, even funding travel for those from states with stricter abortion laws.