Concerns Over Fluoride Removal in NYC
Councilman James Gennaro is facing criticism for his proposal to remove fluoride from New York City’s drinking water—a move some are comparing to the controversial ideas promoted by certain political figures.
Gennaro has been accused by fellow politicians of backing a longshot bill, inspired apparently by Robert F. Kennedy Jr., suggesting that the elimination of fluoride in city water could enhance dental health.
One anonymous colleague remarked, “Perhaps Jim’s thinking was a bit off—like maybe his Tinfoil hat was too tight when he came up with this.” The lawmaker further expressed skepticism about the necessity of such a proposal, stating, “There’s really no reason for this nonsense in New York City.”
Kennedy, known for his previous role as President Trump’s Health and Human Services secretary, has been part of a movement advocating for changes in public health policies, including a call earlier this year for the CDC to reconsider its fluoride guidelines.
Having joined the city council in 2021, Gennaro has been connected with Kennedy for years, even announcing support for Kennedy’s candidacy in the upcoming Democratic primary.
One unnamed councillor pointed out, “The conspiracy theories about fluorinated water are not backed by solid scientific evidence.” They emphasized that science should guide public health decisions, stating, “We can’t afford to roll back proven public health measures.”
Councilman Lincoln Restler, representing Brooklyn, also criticized Gennaro’s proposal, emphasizing that fluoride has been beneficial in improving dental health across socioeconomic lines in New York.
Gennaro’s proposed bill acknowledges the need for further examination, referencing studies that question the safety of fluoride levels in municipal water supplies. It additionally seeks to create a program supplying free fluoride supplements to individuals who request them.
Interestingly, a Gennaro representative mentioned that while he had historically supported fluoridation, “new science has emerged, warranting thoughtful discussion.”
Currently, the CDC endorses fluoride levels of 0.7 mg/L in drinking water, a guideline that matches the levels found in tap water enjoyed by city residents.
