Poll Reveals Majority Support for Horse-Drawn Carriages in Central Park
Amidst growing discussions in the City Council about a ban on horse-drawn carriages, a new poll indicates that most New Yorkers who frequently visit Central Park actually oppose such a ban.
The survey, funded by a union representing carriage drivers, shows that 57% of participants would prefer to ride in a carriage, while 37% think carriages should be relocated to a stable.
Conducted by Slingshot Strategies on behalf of the Transportation Workers Union, the poll emphasized that carriage rides have been a part of Central Park’s charm since its inception, asking respondents for their stance on horse-drawn carriages.
Before revealing their opinions, respondents were told that many see parks as a key aspect of New York’s unique identity and employment opportunities, while others consider horse-drawn carriages to be outdated, unsafe, and inhumane.
The survey specifically targeted New Yorkers who visit Central Park at least once a month and referenced the Rider Act, which was introduced after a horse collapsed and died on city streets three years ago. This event ignited significant outcry from animal rights advocates who allege mistreatment of horses.
If passed, the law would eliminate the horse-drawn carriage industry by June 1, 2026.
Participants were informed of Mayor Eric Adams’ recent executive order, which prepares to phase out carriage rides, citing safety concerns and animal welfare as primary justifications.
Supporters of the industry assert that the horses receive proper care, including regular veterinary check-ups and adequate rest. They argue that banning the carriages would primarily benefit real estate developers looking to build luxury apartments where stables currently operate on Manhattan’s West Side.
The poll concluded with the question: “Do you support or oppose the continuation of horse-drawn carriages in and around Central Park?” A significant 54% of respondents indicated they favor keeping the carriages, while 37% expressed opposition.
Additionally, the survey mentioned that Central Park was designed by Frederick Law Olmsted in the 1850s with the vision of horse-drawn carriage rides providing a serene escape from urban life.
When asked to categorize their views on the role of horse-drawn carriages in the park today, 60% said they should be preserved as a timeless tradition, while 30% felt they should be removed due to being outdated.
Responses to the notion that horse-drawn carriages add “beauty and charm” to Central Park showed that 70% agreed, whereas 23% disagreed. Furthermore, 66% acknowledged that eliminating the carriages would diminish some of the park’s unique charm, while 29% disagreed.
At the survey’s conclusion, after sharing more information, only 24% of respondents supported the ban on horse-drawn carriages, while 60% opposed it, leaving the remaining participants indifferent.
TWU President John Samuelsen emphasized the public’s favor for keeping the carriages, stating that the poll underscores that New Yorkers reject the politically-driven negative rhetoric surrounding horse-drawn carriages. He described them as integral to Central Park’s character and culture.
The poll surveyed 738 New York City residents between September 29 and October 5, with a margin of error of 4.4 percentage points.
Conversely, a different poll conducted by animal rights organizations suggests that a majority of New Yorkers do support a ban on horse-drawn carriages, even after being informed of potential horse abuse accusations. According to this poll, 71% of voters in New York City are in favor of the ban.
