Yankees Reflect on Season After ALDS Exit

Following a four-game sweep by the Blue Jays in the ALDS, the Yankees find themselves once again picking up the pieces of a disappointing season.

A part of the front office’s review involves deciding if they are satisfied with manager Aaron Boone. He’s been with the team for seven years now and recently signed an extension that keeps him with the Yankees through 2027.

Derek Jeter seems to be one of the supporters for Boone’s return, though some fans may not find this particularly reassuring.

“Aaron did a good job,” Jeter said on Fox’s postgame discussion while analyzing the season’s failures with David Ortiz and Alex Rodriguez. “He’s doing what he needs to do and is working hard for the players. I see his enthusiasm.”

“I’m not claiming this based on insider knowledge, but it seems to me that Aaron isn’t the one calling all the shots during the games.”

While Boone holds the managerial title, it’s commonly believed that the front office, especially general manager Brian Cashman, is behind most of the key decisions.

This perception has led to some fan complaints about the front office leaning too heavily on analytics.

After the Yankees’ 5-2 loss to the Blue Jays in Game 4, Boone received support not only from Jeter but also from former teammate Alex Rodriguez during the FOX Sports postgame show.

“Honestly, as far as the organization goes, Aaron Boone is the guy I want to least blame,” Rodriguez remarked, pointing out the team’s hefty $300 million salary—one of the highest in baseball. “He’s working with some real talent, but I’d say this is among the worst roster structures I’ve ever seen. Having three left-handed catchers and five designated hitters makes things tough for Boone.”

With two years left on his contract, Boone mentioned to reporters after the loss that he anticipates returning next season. The Yankees face a busy offseason ahead, contemplating their approach to free agents like Cody Bellinger, Trent Grisham, and Devin Williams, among others.