Governor Hochul Vetoes Bill Following Paramedic’s Tragic Death
Governor Kathy Hochul has vetoed a proposed bill that aimed to mandate dispatching two qualified medical responders to emergency calls in New York City. This bill was inspired by the tragic stabbing of paramedic Lt. Alison Russo in 2022.
In her veto message from October 16, Hochul expressed concerns that the bill would “create financial and workforce challenges” for the city, estimating that it would require hiring an additional 290 paramedics, costing around $25 million.
She highlighted that the Fire Department of New York (FDNY) notified her it might need to reassign medical technicians to work alongside supervisors on emergency calls, potentially decreasing the number of ambulances available.
The union representing emergency personnel criticized the veto, labeling it as callous and contradictory to the safety of workers.
Oren Barzilai, the president of FDNY EMS Local 2507, stated that modifying the law would have ensured supervisors in ambulances operated as part of teams, like the EMTs and paramedics.
“It’s unfortunate that Lt. Russo’s murder didn’t underscore the dangers of our job enough for a protective bill to be passed,” he added.
The FDNY confirmed on Tuesday that they had advised Hochul to veto the legislation, emphasizing the importance of improving response times for critical medical 911 calls.
In a statement, the FDNY reaffirmed its commitment to public safety, stating, “Our priority is ensuring that first responders can assist those in need promptly and effectively.” They expressed gratitude to Hochul for acknowledging their warnings regarding the potential impact of the bill, which they believed could lead to fewer ambulances on the streets and slower emergency response times.
The FDNY clarified that ambulances are already operated with two paramedics on board. Supervisors typically respond in separate vehicles, overseeing and advising emergency teams, and usually do not remain alone at scenes for extended periods.
Union leaders expressed surprise at Hochul’s assertion that $25 million was a minor expense relative to the FDNY’s $2.6 billion budget and the city’s overall $116 billion budget.
“The ongoing neglect of investment in EMS by City Hall is impacting New Yorkers. Hochul’s veto suggests that financial considerations are prioritized over the safety of dedicated emergency personnel,” Barzilai remarked.
He also mentioned that “New York City continually prioritizes other financial commitments over public safety, while emergency responders face numerous hazards in the line of duty.”
Lt. Alison Russo was fatally attacked by Peter Gysopoulos on September 29, 2022, near the Queens train station.
Following Russo’s death, an FDNY investigation recommended deploying an additional paramedic to assist during 911 calls to enhance safety and situational awareness.
