There was a fresh feeling as Mike Kafka took the reins as interim head coach and Jameis Winston stepped in as the Giants’ starting quarterback for the first time. However, that optimism soon faded into the difficult truth that this team has a knack for losing, extending their losing streak to five games after a 27-20 defeat against the Packers at a windy MetLife Stadium.
Here’s a recap of what unfolded the following day.
— Seeing Jackson Darts on the sidelines was a stark reminder of the fragility of these situations. It was encouraging that he could be on the field after recent concussion protocol. Had he shown severe symptoms, he would’ve been inside to avoid the harsh outdoor conditions and likely wouldn’t have been as mobile. Last week he had to leave the game against Chicago after hitting his head, so seeing him back looking unaffected was a relief. In his debut, Winston looked nearly like his former self, demonstrating his powerful arm with some striking throws. He delivered the ball accurately, though there were a few near interceptions that probably should have happened. Cornerback Carrington Valentine will likely be disappointed after reviewing those missed opportunities. There were moments when the pocket got a bit crowded, and I could easily picture Dart escaping and making plays with his mobility. Would the Giants have scored more than 20 points with Dart on the field? I think so. It’s essential for a more seasoned player to step up if he’s back this week against the Lions in Detroit. Rookies really need to learn these lessons firsthand, and Dart now understands that playing recklessly can backfire. Sure, you might gain an additional first down, but you’ve got to weigh the risks. Concussions are nothing to take lightly. In the past, players returned the week after diagnosis, but this season, only three players have been able to play right after going through protocols. The NFL is being cautious now, recognizing that once a player has a concussion, the likelihood of another increases. Darts has to keep the long view in mind.
— Kafka could have easily kept rookie Abdul Carter’s rule violation under wraps. He could have fined him without anyone knowing better. Instead, Kafka chose to start Carter on defense for the first series, even with Kayvon Thibodeau sidelined. Tomon Fox, who has had limited playing time recently, started in the first six plays. Carter took over on the next series and played the rest of the game. He acknowledged he “made a mistake that hurt the team,” and he was aware there would be “consequences.” Kafka handled the situation well; he didn’t make it a spectacle or disclose the specifics of the violation. Maybe Carter was late to a meeting? In any case, Kafka praised him for his “smart play.” Ensuring accountability among players should remain a priority for Kafka moving forward.
