A rookie reporter in Wyoming resigned and her former employer apologized after a rival newspaper discovered she had used AI to write an article.
Aaron Pelzer, 40, started working at Cody Enterprises in early June with no prior journalism experience. By Aug. 9, he CJ Baker of the Powell Tribune He claimed that some of his writings, including quotes that were completely fabricated, misquoted or combined with other statements, were generated by AI tools.
“Obviously, I would never knowingly try to misquote anyone.”
Baker said he noticed some of Pelzer’s articles contained unnecessarily stilted language and language that he felt was inappropriate for a news story last Friday, so he spoke with Pelzer and Enterprise editor Chris Bacon.
“This incident serves as a stark reminder that human behavior is unpredictable, even under the most benign circumstances,” reads an article purportedly written by Pelzer about last month’s deadly shooting in Yellowstone National Park.
Perhaps even worse, the June 26 article announcing that Larry the Cable Guy had been selected as grand marshal for the Cody Stampede Parade appeared to include a writing tip in the sidebar.
“The 2024 Cody Stampede Parade is poised to be an unforgettable celebration of American independence led by one of comedy’s most beloved figures,” the article states.This structure presents the most important information first, helping the reader get the gist quickly. (emphasis added).”
When Baker confronted Pelzer about the allegations, Pelzer essentially came clean, telling Baker that it was “possible” he had used an AI program to write some of the articles, though he did not name any specific programs he may have used.
Pelzer reportedly told Baker that he had worked several “all-nighters” since taking the job and found that AI tools could “add color and context” to stories.
“I hate to say this is about the future, because this is about now,” Pelzer said, according to Baker.
“Obviously, I would never knowingly try to misquote anyone.”
In his conversation with Baker, Pelzer insisted that he would “correct” any misquotes and “apologise” for them, and said he hoped his gaffe would not tarnish Enterprise’s reputation.
“They are taking my earnings at face value,” he claimed.
Shortly after his meeting with Baker, Pelzer resigned from Enterprise.
On Monday, Enterprise editor Chris Bacon I’m sorryHe was held responsible for failing to better supervise the work of his employees.
“I apologize to my readers for allowing an AI to include words in a story that were never spoken,” Bacon wrote.
Mr Bacon insisted he “took responsibility” and that it was his “job” to spot the fraud, and promised to “try harder” in the future.
Bacon did not name Pelzer in his editorial, but instead blamed the fabricated quotes on a mistake made by “a hurried rookie reporter who trusted an AI.”
So far, Bacon has unearthed AI-generated quotes from seven people who said they had never spoken to Pelzer, including Republican Gov. Mark Gordon of Wyoming.
“In one case, [Pelczar] “The Governor wrote an article about OSHA’s new rules that included quotes from the Governor that were completely fabricated,” Michael Pearlman, a spokesman for the governor, said in an email.
“In the second case, he appears to have fabricated part of a quote and combined it with part of a quote that was included in a news release announcing the new director of the Wyoming Game and Fish Department.”
In another example, Pelzer’s story about a liquor store manager accused of embezzling hundreds of thousands of dollars included a quote purportedly from the store’s owner, Brandon McCarter, who Pelzer reported as calling the allegations against him “incredibly disappointing,” but other media outlets did not report McCarter’s comments.
McCarter told Baker he had never spoken to Pelzer. “Those may be words I said, but they were not words I said,” McCarter explained.
“Journalism requires transparency and accuracy.”
In an interview New York PostBacon seemed to acknowledge that the AI hoax in Pelzer’s article was surprisingly sophisticated: “That’s a very credible quote,” he said.
Enterprise magazine publisher Megan Barton called AI “a new, advanced form of plagiarism.”
“Plagiarism is something that all media outlets have to correct at some point,” she continued. “It’s an ugly part of the job, but the companies that do make the effort to correct (or literally write) these mistakes are the ones with the most credibility.”
Pelzer did not respond to a message left by The Associated Press, The Washington Post reported.
Like Blaze News? Bypass the censorship and sign up for our newsletter to get stories like this directly to your inbox. Register here!
