Attorney for Nassar victims criticizes those in charge of trans policies and the abuse scandal

Backlash Over Simone Biles and Transgender Athletes

The sexual abuse scandal involving Larry Nassar has gained renewed attention, particularly as it relates to the ongoing debate about transgender athletes in women’s sports. Critics, including some who have targeted Simone Biles, have pointed to Nassar’s past offenses to question Biles’s views on the inclusion of trans athletes.

Recently, a representative from U.S. gymnastics informed Fox News Digital that the organization removed its transgender eligibility policy from its website back in May to “assess compliance with the current legal environment.”

John Manley, an attorney representing a female gymnast impacted by Nassar’s actions, drew comparisons between Nassar’s abuse and the participation of biological males in women’s sports. He asserted, “Larry Nassar was sexually assaulting children, which is fundamentally different.”

Interestingly, Manley suggested that the leadership style seen with U.S. gymnastics today mirrors the very same oversight that allowed Nassar’s misconduct to occur. He commented, “I think that’s exactly right. [Female gymnasts] will find themselves in close quarters with trans athletes due to the policies that are set.” He lamented that athletes are not prioritized, stating, “Money and medals come first.”

In February, President Donald Trump signed an executive order aiming to restrict male athletes from competing in women’s sports, but this policy only affects federal agencies, leaving organizations like U.S. Gymnastics unaffected.

Manley questioned the rationale behind the organization’s recent actions, calling their reasoning about “compliance with current legal landscapes” absurd. He suggested it was a fear-driven decision, indicating that organizations like these are wary of negative public perception, akin to situations faced by companies like Bud Light. “The decisions need to prioritize athletes rather than external pressures,” he remarked.

While Manley agrees that the issues with Nassar shouldn’t be pinned on trans athletes, especially minors, he believes there’s been a misunderstanding regarding Biles’s recent comments. “What Simone tried to express was, ‘We shouldn’t blame young athletes,’” he elaborated. It seems that Biles aimed to address the systemic issues rather than place blame on individuals.

In December 2021, Manley represented Biles and other U.S. gymnasts in a $380 million settlement against U.S. gymnastics and the U.S. Olympic and Paralympic Committee (USOPC) for Nassar’s abuse. Lawyers are currently examining a lawsuit by Riley Gaines against the NCAA related to biological males competing in women’s sports, highlighting how this discussion might impact future legal practices.

Manley believes this could be pivotal for the future of women’s sports. “How this situation unfolds will determine if women’s sports continue in their current format or if things shift,” he stated. He also expressed his willingness to pursue legal action against the USOPC if a valid case arises.

“We advocate to protect female athletes,” he affirmed, “and it’s imperative for the USOPC to be proactive, rather than passive.” He wishes for clearer policies that promote equitable competition ahead of the Los Angeles Olympics, yet he admits he’s not overly optimistic. “If the current leadership stays, I fear the policy will remain unchanged by the summer of 2028.”