Governor Hochul and the Parole Board Shuffle

Despite her attempts to reverse what many see as New York’s most troubling criminal justice move in recent years, Governor Kathy Hochul seems hesitant to eliminate the criminal parole board entirely.

Recently, the Senate confirmed four of her nominees to the board. These appointments have filled longstanding vacancies, with some newcomers replacing members who were appointed by former Governor Andrew Cuomo, who left office amid scandal.

Even four years after his resignation, Cuomo has had a significant influence, as he still made up the majority of the board until recently. Perhaps it’s worth noting that the progressive factions in control of the state Senate are unlikely to select candidates who pose a challenge to crime?

This latest round of appointments doesn’t seem poised to change the board’s approach, which has supported the release of at least 43 individuals convicted of killing police officers over the past eight years.

This number could’ve been 44; however, last month’s board meeting staved off a decision on David McClary, a gang member found guilty of murdering police officer Edward Byrne.

Cuomo, who generally adopted a tougher stance on crime than his fellow Democrats, might have benefited from this delay as a way to avoid further embarrassment.

Nevertheless, it seems unlikely that Hochul’s selections—who earn $190,000 for this part-time role—will drastically shift the board’s dynamics.

• Danny O’Donnell is a former left-leaning assemblyman and public defense attorney.
• Darlene Grant Bruce serves on the board for a West Harlem community nonprofit.
• Elizabeth Case is a cannabis law attorney and partner at the politically connected Abrams Fensterman.
• Jose Gomerez’s background seems somewhat unclear; he resigned as Newburgh Police Commissioner after less than three years, having previously been an NYPD veteran from the Dominican Republic.

It’s clear the Senate was unlikely to confirm nominees perceived as tough on crime, indicating the administration’s struggle to keep the judicial system from veering further left.

Meanwhile, Congress is making strides to ease parole eligibility. The “Less” Act of 2021, signed by Hochul early in her term, has allowed many parole violators to leave prison with more facility.

In conclusion, like many, Hochul appears either reluctant or unable—maybe both—to navigate the pressures of leftist influences within this sphere.

As those convicted, like Officer Byrne’s murderer, continue to walk free, it’s only a matter of time before New York voters start demanding candidates who genuinely advocate for law and order.