Former President Joe Biden’s memoir has renewed debate over his presidency, his decision to run again in 2024 and how he describes those choices.
Published Nov. 17, Promise Me, America defends Biden’s record and his bid for a second term. Reviews by New Yorker writer Amy Davidson Sorkin and New York Times critic Jennifer Szalai faulted the book for giving too little attention to questions about Biden’s age, the war in Gaza and aspects of his record on racial equity.
Sorkin wrote that the memoir offers little new insight and portrays Biden as still unwilling to confront the possibility that he should have stepped aside. Szalai argued that a memoir should address its subject’s failures, but said Biden instead seems focused on protecting his legacy. She described his discussion of Gaza and the 2024 campaign as defensive.
Those two decisions—the reelection bid and the administration’s approach to Israel during the Gaza war—have become central to debate over Biden’s account of his time in office.
According to the Associated Press, Biden writes that he believed he was the strongest candidate to defeat Donald Trump and that the Democratic primaries gave him little reason to think he was in trouble. Sorkin and Szalai said he gives insufficient weight to concerns about his age and fitness, even as he acknowledges that his debate performance was poor.
Szalai also argued that Biden presents himself as acted upon by events when discussing the campaign, and is similarly guarded in his account of Gaza.
Other reviewers, including writers at Jacobin, criticized Biden’s description of his relationship with Israel and Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, saying it makes the relationship seem more adversarial than it was. Szalai further faulted the memoir’s treatment of Israeli and Palestinian victims, noting that it names Israeli victims but not Palestinians and uses passive language to describe Palestinian suffering.
Israeli journalist and political commentator Amit Segal described Biden’s account of Israel policy as inconsistent and lacking a clear strategy.
Semafor reporter David Weigel noted that Biden writes about signing 17 executive orders on his first day in office but does not mention an order directing federal agencies to develop racial-equity plans. Weigel also observed that the word “equity” does not appear in the memoir.
Instead, Biden argues that justice was part of each of his legislative achievements, including efforts to ensure equal access to vaccines, Weigel wrote.
Weigel also pointed to the absence of the word “transgender.” Biden had previously called discrimination against transgender people a major civil-rights issue, but the memoir does not mention his first-day order barring discrimination based on gender identity.





