Democrats’ campaign promise to freeze energy costs faces a stark reality check

Spanberger rejects redistricting agreement while Luria contends with allegations of secret negotiations

Texas Gov.-elect Gina Hinojosa plans to begin her term with an emergency freeze on residential electricity rates. But one energy policy expert doubts the move will ease affordability pressures, and warns it could create new problems.

Other Democratic-led states are considering similar measures. Critics say price freezes may be a poor fit for Texas, where electricity is supplied through a competitive market, and could contribute to shortages.

“It’s a campaign promise, but the governor can’t simply order rates to stop changing,” said Sam Romain, chairman of the free-market group Americans for Energy Dominance. “You can’t wave a magic wand and freeze them.”

Romain expects Democrats around the country will eventually have to grapple with how to expand energy production, even as some pursue limits on prices.

“Prices respond to supply and demand. That’s basic economics,” he said, arguing that emergency price controls cannot resolve a shortage of supply.

Democratic proposals vary: some would hold rates down, others would help customers pay their bills, and a few would do both.

Virginia Gov. Abigail Spanberger, who took office in January, has called for a six-year freeze on utility rates as a Florida company seeks to buy the state’s largest energy supplier. She has also proposed tripling monthly bill credits for customers.

New Jersey Gov. Mikie Sherrill pledged to declare an emergency and cap energy rates when she began her term in January 2026. She has since shifted toward using executive orders to create credits that offset electricity costs.

California Gov.-elect Xavier Becerra has promised to freeze utility rates while the state looks for longer-term ways to control costs, describing the issue as a priority.

In Wisconsin, Gov.-elect David Crowley will lead a legislature that considered capping gas and electricity bills at 4% of a qualifying household’s yearly income. Crowley has also backed a plan to limit annual rent increases to 7%.

Ohio Democratic leaders, including House Minority Leader Dani Isaacsohn, have proposed a one-year utility rate freeze as Amy Acton prepares to take office as governor.

Romain says these plans could both leave supply problems unresolved and discourage new energy projects. A rate freeze, he argued, does not build new infrastructure and may make developers less willing to invest if they are unsure they can earn a return.

There are also questions about whether some proposals are legally sound. In Texas, Hinojosa’s plan to rely on emergency powers could face challenges.

Nick Loris, president of C3 Solutions, a conservative coalition focused on energy, environmental and agricultural policy, questioned whether the situation meets the legal threshold for an emergency declaration.

He said the Texas Disaster Act allows a governor to declare disasters and suspend certain laws and regulations, but added that courts and state officials may be skeptical that high utility costs qualify as a disaster.

Romain expects similar legal obstacles elsewhere. Still, he thinks disputes over price controls could open the door to bipartisan work on affordability, particularly if Democrats look for ways to deliver on their promises.

“Democrats understand there’s a supply-side problem,” he said. Their approach differs from Republicans’, he added, but he argued that allowing companies to build and compete could help address it.

Romain said permitting reform could become one area for cooperation, by changing rules that govern energy development. He said he was optimistic that a broad permitting package could move forward soon.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Telegram
WhatsApp

Related News