Brandon Nimmo Reflects on Playing in New York

Brandon Nimmo holds the belief that not every player can thrive in New York. He thinks that some simply can’t navigate the pressures of playing there.

The Rangers outfielder, who previously played for the Mets, was in the Bronx for a three-game series against the Yankees. During a break, he spoke from the dugout about his experiences in Queens and shared insights into what he thinks will help him excel in New York City’s intense atmosphere.

“I discussed this with [agent Scott] Boras, and [Mets owner] Steve Cohen as well as [Mets president of baseball operations] David Stearns,” Nimmo told reporters. “It’s hard to quantify how one adapts to New York—whether it’s a natural fit or just doesn’t work for some. There’s definitely a sense of chemistry that’s difficult to define, but it exists.”

While Nimmo refrained from naming specific players who might struggle in the New York spotlight, he noted the Mets’ woeful 13-22 record this season, attributing it in part to difficulties with integrating new players.

For instance, Marcus Semien, acquired in the deal that sent Nimmo to the Rangers, is currently hitting .208 with a below-average OPS+. Another rookie, Bo Bichette, is facing similar challenges, managing a slash line of .236/.273/.313.

Nimmo, who spent ten years in New York, explained that he now views things differently. He described life in Texas as “easy” and “lazy.” He reiterated what he had previously told The Post, emphasizing that his trade was about baseball—not the Mets’ rumored internal issues.

“It takes a unique kind of player to handle New York, and I’ve come to understand that more clearly,” Nimmo observed.

He’s found success with the Rangers, boasting a .300 batting average and an OPS of .836. Last week, he expressed hope for the Mets, who have recently shown signs of improvement.

On Tuesday, Nimmo shared his wish for his former team to find better fortunes, but acknowledged that his current focus lies elsewhere. “I want them to do well,” he said. “Having played through tough times myself, I know it’s not pleasant. Wishing them luck, but I’m focused on doing my job here.”