Buttigieg harshly criticizes Duffy’s response to the flight halt, but his own Transportation Department failures doom his 2028 campaign

Transportation chief points fingers at Biden and Buttigieg for record delays in safety projects

Pete Buttigieg jumped into the debate over last week’s nationwide flight disruption, taking aim at Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy. The move may have been intended to draw attention to Buttigieg as a possible 2028 presidential candidate, but it also brought renewed scrutiny of his own record at the Transportation Department. He currently sits fifth in polling of potential Democratic contenders.

After Duffy held a press conference about the airport shutdown, Buttigieg mocked his language, saying, “You can just write down the comic book asterisk swearing characters.” Buttigieg then held a news conference of his own, saying he was concerned about events in the national airspace. He also acknowledged he had no inside information and little to add. If Duffy’s remarks left questions unanswered, Buttigieg’s appearance did not offer many answers either.

Criticizing his successor may have been a misstep. Buttigieg’s time as transportation secretary is the main experience he can point to in making a case for higher office, and it remains a contentious part of his record. One episode that continues to draw criticism was his extended absence during a severe supply-chain crisis, when ships were waiting to unload cargo at U.S. ports and shortages were worsening ahead of Christmas.

Buttigieg was on family leave after he and his husband adopted premature twins. After his absence became public, he returned to work and made a series of media appearances. Critics argued that he offered little in the way of solutions, and that he blamed high consumer demand while supporting major Biden administration spending bills that, they say, helped fuel the supply crunch.

There were also problems in the nation’s air travel system during his tenure. In 2023, a nationwide ground stop—the first since the shutdown after the September 11 attacks—halted flights for about 90 minutes. The disruption followed a failure in a system used to alert pilots to hazards, including closed runways. It was one sign of the challenges facing an aging air traffic control network.

Duffy has argued that Buttigieg did too little to address a shortage of air traffic controllers and modernize outdated equipment. He has also accused the previous administration of mishandling recruitment, saying changes to training standards contributed to delays and more trainees leaving the FAA Academy in Oklahoma City.

The FAA said last month that it hired 2,235 air traffic controller trainees in fiscal 2026, exceeding its target and setting a record. Duffy has credited changes made during his tenure for the increase. Buttigieg’s supporters may dispute that account, but the controller shortage and the condition of the system remain central questions in assessing his department’s performance.

Critics have also questioned the administration’s diversity-focused recruitment efforts. In 2024, the FAA’s website described hiring initiatives that included people with certain intellectual, psychiatric, and physical disabilities. If Buttigieg runs for president, opponents are likely to cite those programs and argue that the agency placed too much emphasis on diversity and not enough on operational needs.

Another likely point of debate is how the department used infrastructure funding. Of the $25 billion allocated to the FAA under the bipartisan infrastructure law, critics say only $5 billion went toward modernizing air traffic control towers and systems.

The administration’s electric-vehicle charging program could also draw questions. The 2021 infrastructure law set aside $7.5 billion to help build a national network of 500,000 public chargers by 2030, working alongside private companies. But permitting and other bureaucratic hurdles slowed the effort. More than two years after the law passed, Buttigieg was asked why just eight federally funded charging stations were operating. It was a fair question, especially for a program presented as a major transportation priority.

Buttigieg also backed a $1 billion pilot program focused on racial equity in road construction. The initiative sought to address harm caused by highways built through lower-income Black communities, particularly during the expansion of the interstate system after the 1950s. Critics, including Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis, dismissed the effort as an example of “woke” federal policy.

When asked about the recent airspace shutdown, Buttigieg said his department had worked to upgrade the system and that he had not blamed the Trump administration during outages on his watch. He added that the issue should not be made political. But a 2024 Government Accountability Office report found that 51 of the FAA’s 138 systems were unsustainable, citing outdated functions and difficulty obtaining spare parts. Some modernization projects were still 10 to 13 years from completion, while the agency had no plans to update several other systems, three of which were at least 30 years old.

Buttigieg’s defenders can point to work undertaken during his tenure, and not every problem in the aviation system began with him. Still, the record leaves him open to questions about how quickly the department addressed staffing and aging technology. Duffy is now trying to modernize the system he inherited.

Buttigieg is right that the issue should not be reduced to politics. It is also about performance—and his record at the Transportation Department is likely to remain part of any discussion of his presidential ambitions.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Telegram
WhatsApp

Related News