California voters reject proposed billionaire wealth tax
California avoided what one business executive considers a potentially severe economic setback when voters rejected a proposed tax on billionaires earlier this month. Eric Schiffer, CEO of Patriarch and chairman of Reputation Management Consultants, had warned that the measure could prompt wealthy residents and businesses to leave the state.
Proposition 40 would have imposed a one-time tax equal to 5% of billionaires’ net worth in California. In the Nov. 3 election, just over 52% of voters opposed it. Schiffer, a California entrepreneur, called the result a major win for the state’s economy.
“This could have been a catastrophic blow to California and the people who live here,” he said, adding that the state had been fortunate to avoid it. He likened the proposal to a missile aimed at California and argued that it could have driven out both wealth and jobs.
Schiffer said voters understood the risk of pushing entrepreneurs and their companies out of the state. He also worried that a tax on billionaires could lead to proposals targeting people with smaller fortunes. If billionaires were taxed, he asked, might the threshold eventually extend to people worth hundreds of millions—or even a million dollars?
Before the election, Schiffer had warned that the tax could set off a wave of departures, taking investment, jobs and tax revenue with it. In his view, business owners who had already paid taxes while building their companies might have little reason to stay if faced with another large levy.
He said California had avoided what he called an “asphyxiation of genius”—a risk that, he argued, could have driven some of the state’s most important innovators elsewhere.
After the proposal failed, Schiffer said some billionaire clients and friends who had considered leaving were rethinking their plans. Some, he said, had returned or were preparing to come back. He believes the result kept talented entrepreneurs in California and described it as a reason to celebrate.
The California Democratic Party supported the measure, while several prominent figures, including Gov. Gavin Newsom, opposed it. Some wealthy technology executives also campaigned against it. Google co-founder Sergey Brin reportedly spent more than $100 million to help defeat the initiative.
Supporters said the tax could have raised tens of billions of dollars to fund healthcare for working-class Californians.
Even after the defeat, Schiffer cautioned that wealth-tax proposals could return in other states or at the federal level. He said the vote might influence those discussions, and predicted it could slow efforts to impose similar taxes across the country.
Schiffer argued that voters had recognized the possible economic costs. He thinks the result sends a message to policymakers considering similar measures elsewhere, though the debate over taxing accumulated wealth is unlikely to disappear.






