Democrats in Congress are facing a basic question before they can rally behind a leader: who, exactly, are they prepared to follow?
In the House, some Democrats have yet to commit to making Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries the next speaker. In the Senate, Maryland’s Chris Van Hollen is challenging Chuck Schumer for the Democratic leadership post.
Incoming California Rep. Angela Gonzales-Torres said she was not currently backing Jeffries, arguing that members should have a democratic process and that the decision was about more than one person. Still, no one has announced a challenge to Jeffries, and some of his allies want House Democrats to endorse him without a contested vote.
Incoming Colorado Rep. Jessica Killin, who helped flip her district from Republican to Democratic, said Jeffries deserved a chance to lead the party in the majority. Her fellow Colorado Democrat, Melat Kiros, was not ready to support him, saying members should have a meaningful process even if there is only one candidate.
Some uncertainty is coming from the center, too. Sam Forstag, who won a western Montana district carried by President Trump by 11 points, said he had not committed to anyone and would support the person who could improve how Congress works.
Killin, a former chief of staff to several House Democrats, said the incoming freshman class has more than 100 members and that each should decide how to approach the leadership vote.
Republicans have already chosen their House leadership team, selecting Ohio Rep. Jim Jordan as minority leader over current Majority Leader Steve Scalise. Incoming Missouri Republican Chris Stigall predicted Democrats would have a difficult time settling on their party’s future direction. Getting everyone behind Jeffries, he suggested, would be no small feat.
In the Senate, Van Hollen said recent Democratic wins in states that have not backed the party in years helped prompt his leadership bid. He described the contest as a chance to give senators a choice, much as voters had chosen change in the recent elections.
Schumer has led Senate Democrats for a decade. Van Hollen, who is nearly nine years younger, has the support of at least five Democratic senators or senators-elect. Meanwhile, three members who caucus with Democrats have said they will not support Schumer. Michigan Sen. Elissa Slotkin has also said she will vote against him.
The leadership contests point to divisions between moderates and progressives, as well as between longtime members and newcomers. New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani, a Democrat from Schumer’s home state, declined to endorse him, saying he cared more about how a leader used power than who held the position.
Schumer does have prominent supporters. New York Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand praised his work during the election cycle, while Connecticut Sen. Richard Blumenthal said he would back Schumer despite calling Van Hollen a valued colleague. Arizona Sen. Ruben Gallego, who is aligned with Schumer, said he expected Democrats to pursue their agenda regardless of who led them.
Jeffries also faced criticism from a small group of demonstrators at a Democratic gathering in Colorado last week. They shouted about impeachment and called him a profane insult. Pennsylvania Republican Sen. Dave McCormick said the party was fighting over its identity and whether it would embrace more radical ideas.
Some incoming Democrats reject the idea that their party is fractured. Michigan Rep.-elect Donavan McKinney said Democrats were working toward a shared message. Missouri Rep.-elect Fred Wellman, who defeated Republican Rep. Ann Wagner in a historically Republican district, said internal debate was healthy. California Rep.-elect Eric Jones agreed there were disagreements, but described the conversations as open and generally collaborative.
There are substantive policy differences beneath the leadership debate. Pennsylvania Sen. John Fetterman criticized Van Hollen’s views on Israel and questioned whether he had a realistic path to the leadership post. Progressives, meanwhile, see Van Hollen as more open to their priorities.
Incoming Washington, D.C., delegate Robert White pointed to Van Hollen’s support for D.C. statehood and said he would eliminate the Senate filibuster to achieve it. Van Hollen has said he would not move to end the filibuster immediately, while also calling it an undemocratic provision.
That question could become a difficult test for Democrats. Ending the filibuster may appeal to progressives but alarm moderates, particularly those who won districts that usually vote Republican. Similar tensions could emerge over proposals such as Medicare for All.
Democratic leaders will have to work through these differences before they can expect members to fall in line. For now, the party is still deciding not just who should lead, but what that leadership should mean.






